'Concerns remain' after deadline passes for David Marshall to improve skinny horses' condition

Holly Farm owner David Marshall is under investigation for his treatment of Arabian horses on his Canterbury stud farm.

Holly Farm owner David Marshall is under investigation for his treatment of Arabian horses on his Canterbury stud farm.

A Canterbury horse breeder under investigation after claims he was keeping skinny, wounded and dead animals has made "some improvement", but concerns remain.

The Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI) gave Holly Farm owner David Marshall until the end of May to improve the condition of some of his 70-plus Arabian horses after it received a complaint about skinny horses in January.

MPI's clout in dealing with animal-welfare complaints has since been questioned as it received 12 complaints about Marshall's horses between 2010 and 2017.

The horse's rib cage is visible in this photo taken in January.

The horse's rib cage is visible in this photo taken in January.

Some claim Marshall mistreated horses at his Leeston property for years and authorities took too long to act.

READ MORE: Canterbury's Holly Farm owner David Marshall under investigation over skinny horses

An MPI spokeswoman said the ministry was now "carefully considering" its next steps.

MPI said it found the condition of some horses, like this one photographed in January, needed improving.

MPI said it found the condition of some horses, like this one photographed in January, needed improving.

"We have noted some improvement in the condition of the majority of the horses at Holly Farm, however there remain some concerns regarding the management of the stock."

The latest investigation was sparked after "multiple" complaints, many of which related to a circulating photograph of at least two dead horses in a water-filled offal pit.

Marshall said he had the wellbeing of his horses under control and that complaints about their condition were "unfounded".

Horse neglect photo taken by a complainant in January and sent to MPI.

Horse neglect photo taken by a complainant in January and sent to MPI.

"Their care and daily needs were never lacking."

Ad Feedback

It was a "perception" his horses were "too light", he said.

"At the end of the day I do not have horses die from neglect or malnutrition or lack of provisions."

He claimed he had not been forced to put any animals down, as some complainants had said, but he had euthanised two old, retired mares: "They were just old."

"There is an encouragement to lessen numbers and to improve condition and that's been done via sales and normal procedures that I've undertaken myself."

He had sold at least 10 horses and had about 60 left, he said.

"There's no doubt about it, with autumn conditions being so ideal from being basically through three seasons of drought, the whole situation is streets ahead of where we were in February."

Marshall continued the stud's breeding programme and said he did not see any reason why he could not continue adding to his stock.

"I have not been told that I'm not allowed to buy a horse."

Marshall felt "absolutely bullied and targeted" by a social-media "hate campaign".

Horse-welfare activist Nikki Subritzky said she did not believe a month was enough time to rehabilitate horses in a bad condition.

"It doesn't happen overnight with them when they're so neglected. It takes about a year."

She claimed complaints about Marshall in the past had all ended the same way.;

"We complain, authorities step in, cull a few [horses] off because they don't want to spend the resources on rehabilitating and they think 'Out of sight, out of mind'," Subritzky said.

"Then they leave him to repeat the process."

MPI documents said inspections of Marshall's animals over the years identified no welfare issues or found horses were in "light body condition, but not below minimum standard". Marshall was often advised and educated on stocking rate and feeding.

Last month, experts claimed there was a "major problem" with New Zealand's animal-welfare law, with just 17 inspectors in charge of protecting millions of animals.

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers

Snow expected to ease

Tekapo was temporarily cut off by snow on Thursday.

Conditions look set to improve down south, but thunderstorms threaten the North Island and gales hit the capital.

Rental homes risky for kids

Research from Growing Up in New Zealand's Now We Are Four report showed private rentals had significantly fewer home ...

Children living in rentals are exposed to greater safety risks than those whose families own a home, study shows.

Murder in a tight-knit town video

Natanya Campbell and her mum Wendy Campbell Rodgers were killed when they were making a property inspection in Northland.

It was meant to be a routine work visit, but soon after a flurry of gunshots rang out and two women were left dead.

Family wants victims' bodies home video

The victims of Northland's double fatal shooting were mother and daughter Wendy and Natanya Campbell.

Whanau of two women shot dead in Northland "wearing the clothes of mourning" while they wait for their bodies to be returned.


The disappearing price of premium

2032016 News Photo: Marion van Dijk/Fairfax NZ

Petrol price sign at BP2go Haven Road.

Petrol stations don't show premium fuel prices anymore and it allows gouging, AA says.

Street closed by slip

The road will be closed overnight between the Devon St/Essex St intersection, and the intersection of Landcross St and ...

A section of street in Aro Valley has been cordoned off and a house evacuated after a slip has come down.

Wind hits Wellington flights

Wellington's wind is notorious for giving passengers landing in the city a bumpy landing. (File photo)

Flights have been disrupted in the capital, and some have been diverted.

Winter's bite is back video

Cold Antarctic air is behind the front bringing snow to Tekapo and other parts of the South Island.

Wellington in the firing line with gale-force southerlies on the way.


The purrfect crime

A cheeky cat burglar has been caught in Blenheim

A furry, late night prowler stealing clothes from an unsuspecting resident has been caught on tape.

Project seeks land

The Hurunui River in North Canterbury.

"It gives them a big baseball bat and what have I got?" asks one worried farmer.

Flooded residents 'angry'

Southshore Residents Association chairman Bill Simpson says what happened in Southshore during last weekend's flooding ...

Nearly 350 Southshore residents express "disappointment at the late and inadequate response" to flood risk in their suburb.

Rare kotuku shot

An X-ray shows pellets lodged in the kotuku's body.

There are only 100 left but someone has shot a kotuku. Now the hunt is on for the perpetrator.


Que back being a typical Kiwi kid

Que Langdon is settling back into normal activities after sailing with her father to Australia from Kawhia.

After spending 27 days sailing to Oz with her father, life is back to normal for Que Langdon.

Migrants grow dope

Professionally installed heat lamps and hydroponic equipment were set up in various rooms, including bedrooms, of the ...

Illegal immigrant ring caught growing commercial amounts of cannabis in three rental houses.

Cops swoop on school

Police look for evidence at the back gate of Knighton Normal School.

Officers patrolling grounds after incident at primary school in Hamilton East.

Waikato support for plastic bag levy

90 per cent of mayors support a compulsory levy on plastic bags.

Plastic bag levy will see the cost of groceries go up.


Firewood supplies running out

A roaring fire maybe a thing of the past unless you've stocked up as supplies of firewood  run out in Taranaki with ...

Stock up in summer to avoid being left out in the cold.

A 'hybrid event' flood video

Traffic is reduced to one lane just south of Inglewood.

The amount of rain to fall "far exceeded" standards for severe heavy rain warnings.

Drugs and cash seized

Methamphetamine and cash were recovered when police raided four houses in North Taranaki on Thursday morning. (file photo)

Methamphetamine, cash and vehicles seized in a series of raids in Taranaki this morning.

Woman clung to moving car

Members of the public witnessed one woman's horror as her partner tried to push her out of a moving car on a state ...

Her partner tried to push her out as they drove on the highway. When they stopped, she fled and hid under a truck.


A garden of thoughts

Carly Thomas and her eldest daughter Ava Thomas wander through their large garden.

Reporter Carly Thomas gets philosophical about her crazy garden.

Game could move

Access to upper levels of the Central Energy Trust Arena grandstand has been stopped while fire safety work is carried out.

Fire risk closes upper levels of Central Energy Trust Arena grandstand.

Eating spot hits hard times

Bethany's restaurant, on The Square, has fallen into liquidation.

The reputable restaurant was born out of love and tragedy.

Council's black-list folly

David Clapperton introduced an abhorrent email-interception practice at Horowhenua District Council.

OPINION: Horowhenua boss' email-interception practice is abhorrent.


Log truck overturns

A logging truck overturned at Appleby near Nelson.

Logging truck crash closes road near Nelson.

Battle in the skies

Passengers disembark the first Jetstar flight from Wellington to Nelson. (File photo)

Regional airline boss says "it's a race to the bottom, and we're caught up in it".

Chocolate cake heaven

Phil Lash of Chocolate Velvet.

Chocolate Velvet specialises in happiness; glorious cake happiness.

Crime spree arrest

One man has been arrested as police continue to search for two others following a number of crimes across Nelson last ...

Police have made an arrest in relation to several incidents last weekend.


Cloud of fatal crash still hangs

Lara Glover, 16, died in the car crash on February 19.

Eight teenagers were in the car, but Jayne Glover says the whole region felt the crash that killed her daughter.

Nurses to move to hub

The district nurses will have a similar amount of storage space at the health hub, the review panel says.

Where they need more staff, new technology and better communication, review finds.

No flying fish yet for Blenheim

The runway at Marlborough Airport, which NZ King Salmon wants to see extended. (File photo)

Salmon farmed in the Marlborough Sounds can't be flown out of the region because the local runway's too short.

Ice skating, minus the cold

One of Ice Skate Tour's artificial ice rinks will be set up in central Blenheim for four days in December.

It looks like ice, skates like ice, but a rink bound for Blenheim is definitely not ice.

South Canterbury

Rugby player jailed

Kolinio Yabia Tamanitoakula was jailed for three years, four months and two weeks.

His distressed victim was covered in mud when she ran in front of a car to get help.

Change possible - Falloon

National Party candidate Andrew Falloon met ECan representatives on Thursday, following heated public debate about the ...

Retrofitting plan still on the table, National Party candidate suggests.

Roads reopen, rain continues video

Contractors clear snow from the road at Tekapo on Thursday morning.

Roads to Tekapo reopen as schools send  students home early to avoid flooding.

Boy seriously injured in Timaru

A 12-year-old Westmount School - South Campus Timaru pupil was taken to Timaru Hospital on Thursday with serious ...

Twelve-year-old taken to Timaru Hospital with serious injuries following incident in CBD.


Invercargill i-Site to trial pilot to lure migrants

Venture Southland general manager of tourism, events and community Bobbi Brown and Invercargill i-Site supervisor ...

The Invercargill i-Site has been selected by the Ministry of Business, Information and Employment to run a pilot looking to entice visitors to the region to migrate.

The 9-day garage sale

A vinyl record collection does not reflect the tastes of the current owner, Smith says.

Riversdale hoarder's "rationalisation" leads to nine-day garage sale.

Fishermen demand answers

CRA8 Lobster Industry Association chief executive Malcolm Lawson said consultation on the regulation changes have been ...

Southern fishermen want Primary Industries Minister Nathan Guy to front up over concerns regarding new commercial fishing regulations.

Tougher biosecurity wanted

Ministry for Primary Industries Aquaculture analyst Finn Sumner speaks to the audience at an Invercargill public meeting ...

Southlanders have made it known to MPI staff they want to see tougher biosecurity standards for the marine aquaculture industry.

Ad Feedback