Unicef releases damning child welfare report

Kaleb Hurn died by suicide at the age of 17. A new Unicef report has ranked New Zealand the worst in the world when it ...

Kaleb Hurn died by suicide at the age of 17. A new Unicef report has ranked New Zealand the worst in the world when it comes to teen suicide.

New Zealand frequently sits at the top when it comes to international rankings in tourism and economics. A new Unicef report has ranked us number one in another global measure. This is not one to celebrate.

New Zealand has topped the global teen suicide rankings, again.

Our position in the world was cemented on Thursday by a Unicef report that called into question the wellbeing of Kiwi kids.

Kaleb's dad David Hurn says society has created this problem, now it's up to us to find the solution.

Kaleb's dad David Hurn says society has created this problem, now it's up to us to find the solution.

The Innocenti Report found New Zealand's rate for teen suicides (15-19) was the highest of the 41 OECD and EU countries included. We also came in 38th out of 41 countries when it came to overall health and wellbeing of our young people.

Meanwhile, Portugal topped the list at the right end, with a teen suicide rate of 1.7 per 100,000. Italy and Spain were close behind.


* Unicef report: Wellbeing of Kiwi kids languishes behind other developed countries 
* OPINION: NZ is failing its children and we must do better
New Zealand needs to talk about suicide, bereaved dad says 

The report put New Zealand's teen suicide rate of 15.6 people per 100,000, based on data from 2010. The rate had dropped slightly from the previous comparable report that used 2005 data but more recent figures show we were now headed in the other direction. 

Provisional suicide statistics released by the Coroner's Office, show 51 (16.02 per 100,000) people in the age group died by suicide in the year to June 2016 and 52 (16.41 per 100,000) the previous year.

In an average week two young people would kill themselves, and about 20 young people would be hospitalised for self-harm, according to Youthline.

Unicef NZ chief executive Vivien Maidaborn says the rates don't stand in isolation - a range of societal shortfalls are ...

Unicef NZ chief executive Vivien Maidaborn says the rates don't stand in isolation - a range of societal shortfalls are exacerbating the problem.


Ad Feedback

Kaleb Hurn was one of 46 in the 15-19 age bracket who killed himself during 2014. The Waikato teen was 17 when he took his own life.

His father David Hurn said a mix of societal factors played a big part in the high teen suicide rate.

Acting Minister for Children Amy Adams says the government is committed to putting children at the centre of policy.

Acting Minister for Children Amy Adams says the government is committed to putting children at the centre of policy.

A lack of social skills and face-to-face interactions, an ingrained fear of failure, a fear of being different, and bullying all played a part.

Hurn said New Zealand would never completely eradicate teen suicide but the rates could be significantly lowered by teaching children a few fundamental things.

"We need to show our kids it's OK to be different… there's nothing wrong with failing and it's OK to make mistakes."

Labour's deputy leader and spokesperson for children Jacinda Ardern says child poverty measures are needed to hold those ...

Labour's deputy leader and spokesperson for children Jacinda Ardern says child poverty measures are needed to hold those in power to account.

"It's building up that resilience," Hurn said.

Kiwis needed to look in the mirror and start making changes if they wanted to fix the problem.

"We've created what we have, now it's up to us to create what we want."

Hurn's father died recently and a section of his eulogy resonated: "I didn't grow up to be a rocket scientist; I didn't grow up to be prime minister; I grew up to be me, and I'm the best me that I can be."

Suicide, especially teen suicide, has become a high-profile political issue during the past few months given New Zealand's consistently high rates.

The government is in the midst of writing its new national suicide prevention strategy, which is currently out for public consultation. But the strategy was thrown into the limelight for the wrong reasons after mental health advocate and comedian Mike King quit the consultation panel, calling the draft strategy "deeply flawed".


Unicef chief executive Vivien Maidaborn said the rate should not be considered in isolation. It was influenced by a constellation of other factors, such as socio-economic background, poverty, cultural influences and inequality.

The Unicef report highlighted other areas where New Zealand was doing terribly, including equality where we ranked 26th.

The report also found 19.8 per cent of Kiwi kids were living in relative income poverty, and the neonatal mortality rate was 3.1 children per 1000 (the same as in 2005), and the teenage birth rate was 23.3 births per 1000 females aged 15-19, a reduction from 28.7 per 1000 in 2005.

Asking why the rate was so high might be the wrong question, Maidaborn said.

Historically, New Zealand governments focused on the economy and an economic approach to policy when there was a need for a "whole-life" approach to welfare.

A more honest conversation about income poverty and inequality was necessary, she said.

"We design our economic policy and then try to fix it if we get it wrong for young children [but] it's like we're designing for the middle and most well-off New Zealanders.

"I feel like we have been talking about the economy as a measure of success in our society in collaboration with individual responsibility now for 25 years. That's resulted in a penal welfare system."


Acting Minister for Children Amy Adams said government work was underway to support children and young people's wellbeing, especially our most vulnerable.

Both the newly formed Ministry for Vulnerable Children, Oranga Tamariki and the Ministry of Social Development were involved in "a range of cross-government projects to improve children and young people's wellbeing", she said. 

This included the refreshed suicide prevention strategy, the Mental Health Strategy and implementation of the Youth Mental Health Project, as well as anti-bullying strategies.

She also listed recently announced funding that focussed on at-risk children and families, like $2 billion into Family Income Packages and $28.1 million into Family Start, a home visiting programme that helped the government target support to at-risk children.

Then there's the Child Hardship Package - $790m for up to 100,000 kids in extreme hardship, and increased benefits and tax credits for low-icome families.

"It's important to have child-centred policy," Adams said.

"This is a core focus in the government's four-to-five-year transformation of our care and protection system, and has resulted in a child-centred operating model led by the Ministry for Vulnerable Children, Oranga Tamariki."

Legislation that passed in December 2016 ensured children and young people's views were taken into account in the development of services and policy. And if successful, legislation currently before parliament would establish enhanced complaints processes for children, young people and their families, whānau and caregivers, Adams said.


Labour deputy leader and spokesperson for children's issues Jacinda Ardern said the report's results were "astounding but not surprising".

New Zealand should be striving to be "world-leading" when it came to child wellbeing.

"This is an area where we need to be aspirational," Ardern said.

New Zealand should be setting goals and reporting on progress when it came to child health and wellbeing.

"We need to be lifting our game on child poverty."

The government had dismissed the idea of setting child poverty measures in the past, saying it wanted to focus on getting on with fixing the problem rather than reporting on goals.

"But they're not doing that either."

Arden said she hoped this report, which included sustainable development goals as set out by the UN, would not be dismissed by the government as had been the case with previous Unicef reports.


The World Health organisation has identified youth suicide as an issue that needs addressing.

For countries like New Zealand that have a national strategy in place, "the emphasis can be on evaluation and improvement", the WHO report said.

"The emphasis for these countries is on the timely inclusion of new data and ensuring that the national response improves in effectiveness and efficiency. Effective suicide prevention will require a continuous cycle of learning and doing."

In New Zealand, the Coroner's Office compiles the provisional suicide statistics, while district health boards across the country keep data on events including completed suicides, and attempts that lead to hospital admissions or interaction with mental health services.

While data is being collected and evaluated, there have been recent, loud calls for a Royal Commission of Inquiry into the mental health system, following the publicly organised People's Mental Health Review.

It's important to note people with mental health issues are at higher risk of suicide but many young Kiwis who take their own lives do not have a diagnosed mental illness and never came into contact with mental health services.


Le Va chief executive Monique Faleafa said the teen suicide rate was "unacceptably high".

New Zealand's suicide rate was an anomaly, she said.

While other countries experienced large increases and decreases, our rate remained relatively constant. This made it harder to use the data to figure out what caused and prevented suicide.

What we did know was causal factors were complex, Faleafa said, adding that meant prevention strategies also had to be complex.

Prevention had to happen at all levels: in communities and schools, in legislation and at a societal level.

Faleafa said poverty did not cause suicide but it could be one of the risk factors.

Current initiatives were underway to bring rates down, including the national suicide prevention strategy that was currently under consultations, and a soon-to-be-launched national training programme for those who were likely to come into contact with people at risk of suicide.

Almost 20 years ago, the government released a report on youth suicide, highlighting the high rate in the 15-24 bracket, among males, and among the Maori population.

In 1998, New Zealand had the second highest reported suicide rate for those aged 15-24, the report said. And since then, not much has changed.

Faleafa said while there was good work being done around the country, she hoped the Unicef report would bring "a sense of urgency". 


Lifeline (open 24/7) - 0800 543 354

Depression Helpline (open 24/7) - 0800 111 757

Healthline (open 24/7) - 0800 611 116

Samaritans (open 24/7) - 0800 726 666

Suicide Crisis Helpline (open 24/7) - 0508 828 865 (0508 TAUTOKO). This is a service for people who may be thinking about suicide, or those who are concerned about family or friends.

Youthline (open 24/7) - 0800 376 633. You can also text 234 for free between 8am and midnight, or email talk@youthline.co.nz

0800 WHATSUP children's helpline - phone 0800 9428 787 between 1pm and 10pm on weekdays and from 3pm to 10pm on weekends. Online chat is available from 7pm to 10pm every day at www.whatsup.co.nz.

Kidsline (open 24/7) - 0800 543 754. This service is for children aged 5 to 18. Those who ring between 4pm and 9pm on weekdays will speak to a Kidsline buddy. These are specially trained teenage telephone counsellors.

Your local Rural Support Trust - 0800 787 254 (0800 RURAL HELP)

Alcohol Drug Helpline (open 24/7) - 0800 787 797. You can also text 8691 for free.

 For further information, contact the Mental Health Foundation's free Resource and Information Service (09 623 4812).

 - Stuff


Ad Feedback
special offers

Driver still missing video

The car was almost underneath the Harbour Bridge, after having driven off Curran St, Westhaven. It was later towed, ...

After a car drove into Auckland harbour, a fisherman tried to smash windows and save the person inside.

Air NZ 'restricting sales' video

Air New Zealand is flying long-haul planes to the capital purely to refuel, as the airline struggles to cope with the ...

Air NZ is taking the extraordinary step of restricting ticket sales and halting sales of some international services.

Sport: Indoor bowls team take title

Holy Cross School's champion netballers, winners of the AIMS Games netball tournament which featured 122 teams.

Holy Cross have won the AIMS Games netball title for the second time in three years.

NZ's health ranking low

New Zealand is ranked 32nd out of 188 countries on a range of global health measures related to the UN's health-related ...

New Zealand's child sex abuse rates are among the world's worst, according to a United Nations report.


'They picked my teeth off the road'

Linda Gibson is worried a child could die after she collided with a cyclist on the controversial Island Bay cycleway.

Pedestrian injured in Island Bay bike collision blames cycleway design.

Kebab shop roasted

Upper Hutt kebab store owners must pay a Turkish couple more than $80,000 following the Employment Relations Authority's ...

Upper Hutt eatery fired worker because she wanted another child. Now it faces a $60,000 bill.

'Hard' housing choices 

2308 2013 Photo Ross Giblin, copyright Dominion Post, Fairfax.
Wellington City Council chief executive Kevin Lavery.

Chief exec warns Wellington councillors affordable housing agenda won't be easy to deliver.

'Suspect' suitcase full of clothes

A suspicious suitcase left outside the Treasury in Wellington has been found to be full of clothes.

Police stopped Wellington traffic to examine a case left outside the Treasury.


Flying fox saga divides community

A noisy flying fox at Muka Park in Christchurch has been tearing the local community apart.

Warring neighbourhood groups and tens of thousands of dollars have failed to reach a compromise over a noisy flying fox.

Cheap spots in favour

Cheaper suburbs are finding favour with Christchurch home buyers.

Home buyers opting for cheapest suburbs, while demand slows for pricier spots.

Motel used as crime base

Police followed a stolen car to a Christchurch motel and found a room full of stolen property.

Burglars booked a motel room under a false name and used it as a base to raid dozens of homes, police allege.

Drowned couple remembered

Avneel Ram, 25, and Sheetal Ram, 30, died after their car plunged into a lake in Halswell.

A much-loved couple who drowned in a suburban Christchurch lake will "continue to live" in the hearts of their family.


Chapel's heavenly afterlife

St Mary's Convent Chapel in Hamilton East has been reopened after earthquake strengthening. It used to be connected to ...

Hamilton's historic convent is gone but the chapel that was attached to it has been given a new lease of life.

Gastro risk real

Dr Steve Hrudey, a drinking water expert from University of Alberta, Canada, is boiling drinking water during when ...

An expert says there's nothing stopping another outbreak like Havelock North, and tourists ought to be told.

Housing's election effect

The election has put a damper on Hamilton's housing market.

However, a lift in prices and buyer activity is expected post-election.

New  true blue ducklings

The two whio are believed to be one male and one female. Seen here at 22 days old.

It's estimated there are only 1200 adult whio left.


Three days, three parties

Her family travelled from as far as Kaikohe and Christchurch to celebrate her birthday with her.

One with family, one with friends and one with the rest home to finish off her 109th birthday celebrations.

Myrtle rust could surge

Manukorihi golf club was temporarily closed due to positive tests for myrtle rust in June.

The eradication of myrtle rust might not be possible, the Ministry for Primary Industries says.

Oktoberfest? Nein.

At the Oktoberfest beer festival in 2014, Sam Hagmann played traditional Swiss instrument alphorn to kick off the ...

The annual German festival party has been replaced with a "sophisticated" food and drink pairing event.

High school's redevelopment

Waitara High School Principal Daryl Warburton pictured.
The school is having a lot of changes over the next year.
Daryl ...

Waitara High Principal Daryl Warburton says the redevelopment will make a community space for adults as well as kids.


Voters celebrate Suffrage Day

Sandy Wilde casts her vote on Suffrage Day.

Kiwi women were first in the world to vote in national elections. They celebrated on Tuesday by voting.

Gift horse has bolted video

Punters in Palmerston North brave the cold to enjoy the eats on offer at a food truck Thursday event in The Square.

OPINION: Food truck events are hugely popular, but it seems we don't need them.

The day after the election

What if the election is a dead heat? What would Labour leader Jacinda Ardern and National leader Bill English do then?

OPINION: With deals to be done, the really key day is not September 23, but the day after.

Arrest after fleeing police

Police chased a stolen car on State Highway 1, near Sanson, after it failed to stop.

Two police pursuits in two days after drivers in stolen cars fail to stop.


Person critical

A 40-year-old male was flown to Wellington Hospital in a critical condition following an accident involving two trucks ...

A two-truck crash on SH6 south of Murchison has left a person in a critical condition.

Right to vote marked

Elizabeth Coleman, a relative by marriage of Kate Sheppard, leads walkers from the Church Steps in Nelson during the ...

Suffrage Day walk at Nelson draws 80 people, including a relative of Kate Sheppard.

Leader by example

Green Party leader James Shaw, left, and Nelson candidate Matt Lawrey walk along Rocks Rd in Nelson where Shaw announced ...

Green Party leader James Shaw pledges $23m to fix Rocks Rd.

Brook Stream clear after drop

Landcare Research water testing of the Brook Stream (pictured) post poison drop shows "no detectable residue" the Brook ...

No detectable poison residue found in the Brook Stream after drop the sanctuary says.


Owners highly motivated

New Zealand King Salmon's new barge is launched with air bags acting as rollers.

Four bedrooms, two bathrooms, 240 tonnes of fish feed. Wait, what?

Beaten for saying no

Blenheim man Tui Simon Kara admitted assault with intent to injure at the Blenheim District Court. (File photo)

Blenheim man violently attacks partner after being refused oral sex.

'Burt Munro of the skies' video

Burt Munro with his 1920 Indian Scout motorcycle.

In classic Burt Munro fashion, Graeme Frew's No 35 World War II fighter plane almost didn't make it to the start.

Driver critical after crash

A 40-year-old male was flown to Wellington Hospital in a critical condition following an accident involving two trucks ...

A two-truck crash on SH65 south of Murchison left a person in a critical condition.

South Canterbury

Parking meters stolen

Six parking meters have been stolen in Timaru, four from Bank St, and the other two from Strathallan St.

Police are looking for information after the theft of six parking meters in Timaru.

Rules could change

Minister Nick Smith said he endorsed the idea low-emission burners should only be introduced when old burners have ...

Meeting told Nick Smith will progress changes to national air standards.

Two escape fire video

Two people are in hospital after a well involved house fire near Timaru on Tuesday morning.

Elderly man carried wife over his shoulder as their house burned to the ground.

Fairlie helps crash victims

Fairlie Volunteer Fire Brigade firefighter Jeff Haugh, school bus driver Astrid Johns and firefighter Sam Haugh were ...

Bus driver, dairy owner and emergency staff among those who responded to bus crash.


Clyde's 'day of reckoning'

Central Otago mayor Tim Cadogan above Clyde.

The Central Otago township of Clyde faces a potential $34 million sewage system upgrade to meet national water policy standards.

Pair rescued from waterfall

Two people have been rescued from the top of a waterfall near Queenstown. (File photo)

Two people have been rescued from a steep track above a waterfall at a popular rockclimbing spot near Queenstown.

No Southern Utd games for Invercargill

Southern United's Michael Hogan challenges Leo Villa from Team Wellington in the air during their match at Rugby Park in ...

While Southern United won't play any national league matches in Invercargill this summer, they are still likely to visit the deep south.

Changes under way at hospital

An independent review of Dunedin Hospital's urology department has been carried out after several patients experienced ...

Health Minister expresses ''full confidence'' in Dunedin Hospital management after concerns were raised over life-threatening delays.


Upgrade planned for Elles Rd intersection

Lake St was the site of a crash between a train and a logging truck earlier in September.

One of Invercargill's most hazardous intersections is set for a major upgrade.

Tiwai celebrates

NZ Aluminium Smelters general manager Gretta Stephens, with Southland Girls' High School students Imogen Brankin, Tayla ...

Southland Girls' High School and New Zealand Aluminium Smelters are celebrating 10 years of working together.

Grandad makes innovative playground

Neil Hall watches his grandson, Jack Shepherd, having fun in the playground he built using a 1946 Austin truck.

Jack Shepherd is having a ball in the playground made by his grandad.

Seal lion shot

Department of Conservation staff have found a second critically endangered sea lion shot on a Catlins beach.

DOC staff have found a second critically endangered sea lion shot.

Ad Feedback