Outspoken support for the cannabis status quo is hard to find

Police keep trying to disrupt cannabis growing operations, but not that many people seem to want to speak out loudly in ...
MARTIN DE RUYTER/ FAIRFAX NZ

Police keep trying to disrupt cannabis growing operations, but not that many people seem to want to speak out loudly in favour of the current laws.

For a law that has been so hard to change, the criminalisation of cannabis seems to have few outspoken supporters.

Senior members of the Government will fight their corner if pushed, but it's hard to find a detailed defence from the people who make the laws of the cannabis status quo.

When questioned, Prime Minister Bill English said cannabis did "real damage" to people, particularly when combined with mental health problems.

Health Minister Dr Jonathan Coleman was not in favour of decriminalising cannabis, saying we have "too many drugs in society" andJohn Key, when he was still prime minister, painted a scenario where cannabis stores would sprout on street corners

"You show me the communities who want to put up their hand and say I want a tinny house at the end of my street?" he said.

STAUNCHLY CONSERVATIVE

Bob McCoskrie, director of Family First New Zealand seems to be one of the few outspoken supporters of the current ...
LAWRENCE SMITH/FAIRFAX NZ

Bob McCoskrie, director of Family First New Zealand seems to be one of the few outspoken supporters of the current cannabis laws.

It appears to be left to Family First NZ national director Bob McCoskrie to mount a stout defence of the status quo.

His conservative Christian lobby group has welcomed a cautious approach to medicinal marijuana. But any hint of liberalising cannabis laws, McCoskrie said, is the wrong path if we care about public health, public safety, and our young people.

"There is a false dichotomy that criminal sanctions apparently haven't worked, so we should ditch them altogether and we should focus only on education and health initiatives," he said. "We should maintain both."

Former Prime Minister John Key questioned whether people would want tinny houses at the end of their street.
ANDY JACKSON/FAIRFAX NZ

Former Prime Minister John Key questioned whether people would want tinny houses at the end of their street.

Claims that hundreds of people were being locked up for petty drug offences were debunked by Ministry of Justice statistics showing fewer than 10 people were given prison sentences for cannabis possession offences in each of the past three years, he said.

Ad Feedback

"Erroneous claims that we are wasting time and resources focusing on the criminal aspect fail to understand that there has been a substantial decline in arrests for cannabis use in New Zealand over the past decade, and that police diversion and Alcohol and Other Drug Treatment (AODT) Courts have been increasingly used," McCoskrie said.

"But it is the application of the law which enables these orders to be made and enforced in the first place."

Prime Minister Bill English: doesn't want to shift the boundary.

Prime Minister Bill English: doesn't want to shift the boundary.

POLICE TIME

The idea that legalising cannabis will free up police time was described as "naive" by New Zealand Police Association president Chris Cahill, who said police spend little time dealing with cannabis-only offending.

"The reality is that the only targeted cannabis policing is around the dealing of cannabis," he said. "They don't target the users of cannabis.

The Police Association president says police "don't target the users of cannabis".
RICKY WILSON/FAIRFAX NZ

The Police Association president says police "don't target the users of cannabis".

"A lot of these cannabis houses are also dealing methamphetamine, so that's the main target, but at times the cannabis is included across that.

"As far as people being charged with just 'possession of cannabis' offences, the vast majority of those charges are add-ons to more serious offending."

The discussion on legalisation of cannabis was not a simple one, he added.

"While we're probably relatively comfortable that people shouldn't necessarily be receiving a lot of convictions for just possession of cannabis, the idea of legalising it has lots of other implications.

"For instance, while an adult who smokes a joint of cannabis on a Saturday night may not be at any serious health risk, 13 or 14-year-old youths that smoke cannabis is a totally different situation, and that needs to be understood."

POLITICAL VIEWS

Should New Zealand legalise cannabis?

Share your stories, photos and videos.

Former Act MP Dr Muriel Newman takes a tough line on cannabis.

"While supporters of more liberal cannabis laws often say that smoking the drug is a victimless crime, the facts show the opposite," she wrote in a post on the website of the New Zealand Centre for Political Research, which she founded.

She was referring to a NZ Transport Agency report, which looked at the dangers of drugged driving. The report said a study of the blood of deceased New Zealand drivers found 30 per cent of them had used cannabis with or without alcohol or other drugs.

 

"Cannabis is clearly a very dangerous drug, especially for young people," Newman said.

Columnist Mike Yardley reckoned "you'd have to be off your scone" to support a referendum on decriminalising cannabis for personal use.

"Two per cent of Kiwis have graduated from the gateway drug of cannabis to become meth-heads. Should we adopt a similarly defeatist attitude to methamphetamine's legal status quo?" he wrote.

Yardley pointed to data from the National Committee for Addiction Treatment showing 55 per cent of New Zealand prison inmates were cannabis dependent.

"It fuels crime," he said. "And we're all paying the price for cannabis dependence through its devastating impact on mental health."

AUSSIE APPROACH

Drug Free Australia's supports a "balanced and humane illicit drug policy".
STEVE DIPAOLA/REUTERS

Drug Free Australia's supports a "balanced and humane illicit drug policy".

Across the Tasman there seems to be a concerted effort to halt any attempt to make access to cannabis easier.

Drug Free Australia's position statement is that it supports a "balanced and humane illicit drug policy that aims at demand reduction, primary prevention and recovery-focused rehabilitation".

"This can never be achieved if illicit drugs are condoned through their legalisation," it said. Accessibility, availability and permissibility would all increase consumption.

 

Two leading officers of Drug Free Australia were among the authors of a paper that argued against relaxing the law on the use of cannabis for medical purposes.

"Cannabis is, globally, the most used illicit drug, which in itself creates a significant challenge. By legalising it for ‘medical’ purposes, use rates would soar, as this would constitute ‘acceptance’ of the substance and send a message that it is ‘safe’ to use," the paper said.

Any measure of government policy that could influence increased recreational use would be highly detrimental. Studies showed "a continually increasing case against increased cannabis use because of the high risk to the health of users, their children, and in the overall social costs to the wider community".

DOCTOR'S ORDERS

In New Zealand, medical professionals warn about the dangers of cannabis, but that doesn't mean they are in favour of the status quo.

For example, an editorial in the New Zealand Medical Journal in 2016 noted there was good evidence of the harms associated with cannabis use.

How has cannabis affected your life?

Share your stories, photos and videos.

Population-based studies showed increased rates of psychosis associated with cannabis use, individuals identified mental and physical harms, and there were likely to be carcinogenic effects related to the smoking of cannabis.

The editorial noted the medical evidence to support medicinal use of cannabis was "weak".

"There is speculation that patients may use cannabis simply because it makes them feel better," the editorial said.

Despite talking about harm caused by cannabis, it also said it was time to review the prohibition of cannabis.

GOVERNMENT VIEW

The Government has a National Drug Policy - for 2015 to 2020 - but it doesn't really read like a ringing endorsement of the cannabis status quo.

In the policy's foreword, Associate Health Minister Peter Dunne said the Government's approach to minimising harm from alcohol and other drug misuse "needs to be compassionate, innovative and proportionate".

"This recognises that alcohol and other drug problems are first and foremost health issues."

It was necessary to be prepared to challenge traditional approaches, Dunne said.

"The international landscape has also shifted, with a growing recognition that the harms we are trying to prevent can come from our approach to drugs as much as from their use."

One of the policy's goals is to control supply, which includes "shutting down domestic growing, manufacturing and supply".

PUBLIC VIEW

Only about a third of the public support the existing law prohibiting possession of cannabis for personal use, according to a poll commissioned by the Drug Foundation in 2016.

More than 1000 people took part in the survey in July and August last year, with 34 per cent in favour of retaining prohibition on possessing a small amount of cannabis for personal use. A third thought it should be legal and 31 per cent thought it should be decriminalised - the strongest majority the foundation had seen in favour of reforming the drug law, according to executive director Ross Bell.

Of those who took part, 44 per cent wanted personal growing to remain illegal, 76 per cent wanted growing for friends to stay illegal and 64 per cent wanted selling from a store to be illegal. When it came to growing or using cannabis for medical reasons such as alleviating pain, only 16 per cent thought it should be illegal, with the figure edging down to 15 per cent for people with a terminal illness.

Comments have been closed. 

 - Stuff

Comments

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Rail better than road-based solutions

PTUA chairwoman Christine Rose wants to see diesel trains used for a passenger rail service to and from Huapai.

Members of the Public Transport Association, Kumeu Residents and Ratepayers and Rodney councillor Greg Sayers recently met with Auckland Transport's chief executive to discuss trains to Huapai.

Tourist located thanks to Facebook

Valeria Mikhailov was hiking through the Herekino Forest when she sent four 'help' signals from her GPS tracker back to ...

A call for help from a woman in Russia saw a group of New Zealanders spring into action to find her daughter.

Have a say on health services

Waitemata DHB public health medicine registrar Carol Barker is leading the survey for South Kaipara residents.

Locals living in South Kaipara are being asked for their thoughts on health services.

Rush-hour rain in Auckland, Dunedin

Commuters are being advised to take care on their way home.

Weather fronts are bearing down on both Auckland and Dunedin.

Wellington

Capital's fake yellow lines go legit

After 20 years of painting  illegal broken yellow lines on Wellington's Holloway Rd, Russell Taylor may soon be able to ...

Russell Taylor and his paint brush are about to win their 20-year war with Wellington City Council.

'A lovely, caring man'

Sid Hanzlik, who died after a small fire outside parliament, is understood to have been aggrieved after dealings with ...

Neighbour tells of shock at death of Sid Hanzlik after fire on Parliament grounds.

'Asthma destroys families'

Alicia Kirkpatrick died at the age of 29, leaving behind three young children.

Father calls for better education about the risks of asthma after death of his daughter.

Compulsory te reo at Welly school

More than 250 year 9 students at Wellington Girls' College will learn Māori for at least half the school year in 2018. ...

From next year, more than 250 year 9s at Wellington Girls' College will learn Māori.

Canterbury

Fight to stay in the country video

Seamus Robertson with his fiancee, Pham Thu Thuong Nguyen, at his father's property in Eyrewell, where the couple have ...

Man faces having to leave his terminally ill father to be with the woman he loves after her visa was declined.

Screams during killing

The body of Marcus Luke Tucker, 36, was found bound and wrapped in carpet near Lake Ellesmere on Anzac Day 2016.

Woman breaks down in court recounting her friend screaming for help during a fatal bashing in her bedroom.

Suspect beaten up behind bars

Kasha William Gosset, 35, is one of two men charged with the murder of Bradley Lomax, 24.

Several prisoners assaulted a man charged with Bradley Lomax's murder.

Religion-in-schools protested

Secular Education Network campaigner Tanya Jacob and volunteers will be outside Christchurch schools from Wednesday.

Group claims children told to donate pocket money and evangelise, but provider says they are misinformed.

Waikato

Waitomo Hilltop Glamping

Two claw foot baths sit on a wooden deck, water is heated from wetback fire.

Waitomo couple discover market in convincing Aucklanders a farm is a holiday.

Fishing spot's grim toll

Caroline Swann keeps records of deaths and near drownings observed over her 73 years at Papanui Point.

In an old box a farmer tallies the details of the 18 people who died on her patch of coast.

DHB member defiant on Chiefs deal

Waikato DHB member Mary Anne Gill was elected to the board in 2016.

It cost taxpayers $50,000 but Waikato DHB members want to move on from the bungled Chiefs contract.

Helping hand through Hangman 

Kiwi MMA star Dan Hooker will help train fighters for the Hangman Challenge.

Dave Sawyer wants to help those "that are in a bad place" through his MMA event.

Taranaki

Fight for flower power

19092017   News   photo: Warwick Smith/Stuff
Orchid grower Alan Rae in his propagation shelter amongst his cymbidium ...

 OPINION: Where does your florist source their flowers?

Flooding on roads

Water has flooded across some roads in south and coastal Taranaki. (file photo)

"It's covered most of the south bound lane in dirt and rocks."

Prankster set off alarm

A crowd enjoys the outside fire at New Plymouth's Snug Lounge. (file photo).

When someone set off the alarm in a bar toilet patrons were evacuated, most came back to pay their tabs.

Stress forcing principals out

Lepperton Primary School principal Charles Gibson says he has been congratulated by other principals for getting out of ...

Principal Charles Gibson is leaving his job, and he's had more congratulations than commiserations.

Manawatu

Two awards in one week

Heather Knox with co-founding Palmy Rocker Kate Parlane setting up August's "Palmy Rocks: We Are One" photo exhibition.

Palmy Rocks' Heather Knox would like council to have a comprehensive play policy

Fatal driving admitted

Josh McGinty, 17, died after the driver of the car he was in failed to give way at an intersection.

Restricted driver failing to give way results in the death of her passenger.

Cancer patient fighting to live video

Kerry McGrath wants to live her dream and travel the country in her house bus. But she needs some help to do so.

Kerry McGrath just wants to get to living in her gypsy house bus, cancer-free.

Manawatū Gorge: Your thoughts stuff nation

What should be done about the Manawatū Gorge?

We want to hear your thoughts, experiences and ideas about this beautiful, yet geologically unstable, landmark.

Nelson

Farmers' Market heads riverside

Miriam Clark, manager of Nelson Farmers Market, in Morrison Square.

Nelson's Farmers' Market is to shift from the CBD to a new riverside location.

Fire prompts reminder

The fire that took hold of a house in Washington Valley is thought to have started when embers were blown underneath the ...

Ceiling fire in Nelson a strong message about clean chimneys says Fire Service.

Ice pilot Leachman laid to rest

The acting Chief of the Royal New Zealand Navy James Gilmour, left, and fellow Navy officers salute the late Andrew ...

Friends and family of Andrew Leachman farewelled a man whose life was as musical as it was nautical.

Robbery "look-out" pleads guilty

Jacob Harmon has admitted to playing a role in a recent armed robbery in Nelson.

Judge tells man who played "look out" for an armed robbery that jail time is likely.

Marlborough

Little town the sculptor forgot video

Twisted iron from the quake-damaged railway line bears the names of affected townships around Kaikōura, including Oaro, ...

It's not the first, and it probably won't be the last, time someone has asked 'where's Rakautara?' But this time, it's a resident asking.

Muddy cover-up fails

Reid Kevin Heyward has been caught poaching up the Awatere Valley in Marlborough. (File photo)

The number plates were carefully covered in mud so no-one could identify the truck. But then the farmer showed up.

Threatened for testifying

Police target boy racers doing burnouts on public roads. (File photo)

"Good luck, you're stuck with me forever," says teen, as she threatens to send her boy racer mates around.

Grape result for young vintner

Young Winemaker of the Year winner Kelsey Daniels from Vinlink Marlborough works on her blending skills.

A Marlborough vintner keeps young winemaker award in the region.

South Canterbury

Swooping magpies concern

Shirley Halkett is dive bombed by a protective magpie while cycling in the Scenic Reserve.

Cyclists call for signage warning of the dangers of nesting magpies in a Timaru reserve.

Fine weather back

A severe weather warning was in place for heavy winds in Canterbury on Monday morning.

The majority of South Canterbury is expected to have fine weather on Tuesday.

Event fundraiser a success

Olympian Jock Paget claybird shooting at Craigmore Station before the first fundraiser for a proposed $250,000 new ...

First fundraiser for proposed eventing venue an 'absolute success', spokeswoman says.

Expo burglary disappoints

The Caroline Bay Hall was being used for the Big Brand Surf, Street, Skate Clothing & Shoes Sale Expo, run by company ...

More than $1000 worth of clothing stolen from clothing expo at Caroline Bay Hall.

Otago

Car parking restrictions coming

Queenstown Lakes District Council proposed to build three new bus stops on Camp St, two near Shotover St roundabout.

"To make transport more efficient, economic and possibly more enjoyable, a behavioural change is required." Tony Pickard

Exit package prompts questions

Under-fire Aurora Energy chief executive Grady Cameron.

Dunedin councillors have questioned a golden handshake to an outgoing chief executive of an under-fire lines company.

Premises needed for Frankton library

There's a "real desire" for a library in Frankton, Queenstown Lakes District Council say.

Expression of interest for a short-term Frankton Library in Queenstown is open.

Dashed wedding turnaround

Central Otago Wedding Fair 'Dream Wedding' winners Ashleigh Sinclair and Jai Beck, of Clyde.

A Clyde couple who cancelled their wedding after falling pregnant will still get to walk down the aisle.

Southland

Craig focus remains on health, housing

Labour candidate for Invercargill Dr Liz Craig at the Newfield Tavern in Invercargill on election night, who is to ...

New MP looking forward to working for Invercargill constituents.

Policy considered

The council introduced its captive bolt gun policy in April 2016, with the support of the local branch of SPCA.

An urgent recommendation on the Invercargill City Council's dog euthanasia policy is expected to be put forward at a meeting this afternoon.

Centenarian gains family

Wallace Price, left, with his son Graeme at the Grasmere Kindergarten to vote in the 2017 general election.

Among the gifts Wallace Price received for his 100th birthday he got a whole new side to the family.

They're 'flooding my family farm' video

Looking out over the Hollyburn creek which has been flooded by water from the Waiau river.

Every time Meridian Energy releases the Manapouri dam, Thomas O'Brien loses another chunk of farmland.

Ad Feedback