Report finds safety testing flaws before tuk-tuk crash that injured six people in Wellington

The report into a tuk-tuk crash in Wellington in December, which injured six people, shows the canopy collapsed on ...
SUPPLIED

The report into a tuk-tuk crash in Wellington in December, which injured six people, shows the canopy collapsed on impact, endangering passengers.

A report into a tuk-tuk crash in Wellington late last year has revealed safety testing flaws put passengers at risk, and probably led to the injuries suffered by six people on board.

The $30,000 investigation into the crash, on Wellington's steep and winding Roseneath Tce in December, was commissioned by the New Zealand Transport Agency after its inspection of the tuk-tuk following the incident raised concerns about its stability and "rollover" strength.

According to the report, obtained under the Official Information Act, five passengers suffered head and facial injuries in the accident, including concussion, cuts and bruises, which required emergency medical care or hospital treatment.

The front right side of the tuk-tuk was significantly damaged.
SUPPLIED

The front right side of the tuk-tuk was significantly damaged.

The report says the vehicle's metal canopy offered "little to no resistance" to the crash, and its supporting pillars also failed to withstand the impact.

READ MORE:
Tuk-tuk licences revoked after Wellington crash investigation
Tuk-tuk tours on hold after crash injures six
Tuk-tuk rolls in Roseneath hills

Tuk-tuks were certified as passenger service vehicles in September, and operated in Wellington and Auckland until they were taken off the roads in February.

The toppled tuk-tuk at the crash scene, in Roseneath Tce, Wellington.
SUPPLIED

The toppled tuk-tuk at the crash scene, in Roseneath Tce, Wellington.

The report, signed off in January, shows the vehicles were incorrectly given safety certificates and, had the issues been addressed, "the level of injuries would likely have been reduced".

"The condition of the vehicle does not meet the expected behaviour of a rollover frame; the vehicle structure has failed to provide reasonable protection to occupants."

WHY WERE TUK-TUKS INCORRECTLY CERTIFIED?

The canopy was not able to withstand the impact of the crash, instead buckling and collapsing.
SUPPLIED

The canopy was not able to withstand the impact of the crash, instead buckling and collapsing.

NZTA hired Palmerston North-based company Sandbox Consulting to investigate the tuk-tuk's performance in the crash and, subsequently, to recommend design changes to improve the vehicles' stability.

Ad Feedback

According to the report, the error occurred because shortcuts were taken during safety testing that deemed the tuk-tuks to be roadworthy.

NZTA rules require a passenger service vehicle to be able to withstand an impact, at its highest corner, of half its maximum weight from side-on and total unladen weight from above, without sustaining permanent damage.

Police officers tend to injured occupants of the tuk-tuk. Skid marks can also be seen on the road.
SUPPLIED

Police officers tend to injured occupants of the tuk-tuk. Skid marks can also be seen on the road.

The independent engineer who issued the safety certificates for the vehicles operated in Wellington by Tuk Tuk Cartel erred by assuming the three-wheeled tuk-tuks would absorb the impact in the same way as heavy vehicles, such as buses, the report says.

The incorrect method was used for "expediency", when a separate analysis should have been carried out.

Unlike a heavy vehicle, the tuk-tuks would be unlikely to evenly distribute the force of any impact, making the front more vulnerable should it hit the ground and potentially "leading to failure".

The report also finds the steel canopy did not qualify as a rigid structure, as is assumed of heavy vehicles.

The police serious crash unit investigated the accident and deemed neither the driver nor Tuk Tuk Cartel was at fault.

Glen Varcoe, who set up Tuk Tuk Cartel with his brother Jeremy Marr, said the report appeared "interesting", and he would take a couple of days to consider it before commenting further.

NZTA said on Monday that the independent engineer involved was currently being investigated by the Institution of Professional Engineers.

He was issuing safety certificates as "a suitable qualified person", an NZTA spokeswoman said, but was not an NZTA appointee.

"Because there is an ongoing investigation, the Transport Agency is not able to comment on the circumstances that resulted in the vehicles being deemed compliant with PSV requirements.

"All Transport Agency-appointed independent vehicle certifiers are subject to performance monitoring and auditing by the agency with respect to certifications carried out under those appointments."

She added: "The process used for certifying the vehicles as passenger service vehicles was the correct one, but the crash investigation by the NZTA has indicated that the vehicles did not comply with the relevant technical requirements of the passenger service vehicle rule."

WHAT NOW?

New testing criteria has been introduced to assess the stability of three-wheeled vehicles before they are issued with a certificate of fitness.

The testing will ensure "real-world stability" similar to that of a four-wheeled vehicle, and includes a raft of engineering calculations. 

It was unclear whether the necessary improvements could be made to tuk-tuks to bring them to an acceptable safety level, the report said.

NZTA said it was up to tuk-tuk operators to decide if they wanted to reapply for an operating licence if and when they were deemed roadworthy.

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Garden inspires couple's art

Clivia flowers in their garden inspired Rod Upchurch's first floral piece.

A Kumeu couple will exhibit landscape and floral art pieces in an upcoming exhibition Outside in.

Man attempts to grab boy

Police are investigating a suspicious approach in Auckland.

A man in a hoodie jumps out of a black car and chases an 8-year-old, trying to grab him, on Auckland's North Shore.

Dealing with death at Auckland Zoo

Auckland Zoo's Sumatran tiger Jaka was put down in August after vets found a large inoperable tumour in his intestine.

Zoo animals continue contributing to science in death.

'Business as usual' soon

Energy minister Judith Collins (file).

Energy Minister Judith Collins says Auckland airport's fuel crisis is coming to end.

Wellington

Prestigious Hutt home gallery

The former Upper Hutt home of one of New Zealand's most distinctive residential architects, James Chapman-Taylor, is on ...

Celebrated Lower Hutt architect's home back on market.

Man on fire dies

Cordons were set up around Parliament after the incident.

The man who reportedly set himself on fire outside Parliament has died overnight, police say.

Cannabis and guns seized

A rifle and about 100 cannabis plants were seized by police.

Cannabis plants and rifle found at property in small Hawke's Bay settlement.

Car and train collide

The scene of the crash at Ohau, where a motorist died when their car collided with a northbound train.

A car driver died after a crash with a train on State Highway 1, south of Levin.

Canterbury

What's with the giant spray cans?

Some of the cans will be used for workshops and for young street artists to practise.

The 4.5 metre-high cans are part of a new space coming to central Christchurch.

Disappearance baffles

Amber-Lee Cruickshank, pictured age one, went missing on October 17, 1992.

Police travelled to Aussie outback for answers about what happened to toddler Amber-Lee Cruickshank.

Ram raid car theft video

Corrie Dewagt, Panel shop foreman at Andrews & Gilmore Panel & Paint looks down at broken pieces of a gate. A Nissan ...

Thieves smashed way into a panel beater's and took a Nissan Skyline GTR.

Victim forced to tie up family

Police guard Andrew Cameron's house near Hanmer Springs on Tuesday morning.

Kidnapping victim forced to tie up family members while gun pointed at his head.

Waikato

A year's rain in 9 months

Waikato residents have been forced to find shelter where they can over the past nine months (file photo)

Rainfall records tumble as Waikato wades through wettest year ever.

Crash driver critical

Ambulance officers were called to the crash on Highway 22.

A driver is in a critical condition after rolling his car on a highway near Huntly. 

Killer highway's $6m salve

Two people were killed on SH3 between 2005 and 2014.

Rumble strips, side barriers and intersection improvements on the way for SH3.

Monster slip chases woman video

A large slip has taken out many acres on a farm near Te Kuiti.

Joanne Tapara outran an avalanche of rock and mud that claimed 6 cows, 40 ewes and 70 lambs.

Taranaki

The 'downhill slide'

11092017 News Photo ANDY JACKSON/STUFF.  The Ticking Timebomb, a series looking at the rising issues of Alzheimers ...

He's forgotten how to peel potatoes but fears forgetting his children most.

Armed cops in street

Firefighters don hazmat suits at the scene on Turakina St.

Officers who entered a suspected clandestine lab have been put through a decontamination shower.

Home stretch awaits Hareb

Paige Hareb is looking to make her presence felt in her final two events of the year.

She's been in contention all year, now the Kiwi surfer knows it's time to lock in her qualification to the world tour.

Dementia: a love story video

11092017 News Photo ANDY JACKSON/STUFF.  The Ticking Timebomb, a series looking at the rising issues of alzheimers ...

Tom Matiaha's 24 years as a soldier could not prepare him for his family's battle against a hidden foe: Alzheimer's disease.

Manawatu

Car and train collide

The scene of the crash at Ohau, where a motorist died when their car collided with a northbound train.

A car driver died after a crash with a train on State Highway 1, south of Levin.

Ambulance at car fire

Emergency services respond to a car on fire at the corner of Napier Rd and Te Matai Rd, north of Palmerston North.

Emergency services are rushing to a car on fire near Palmerston North.

No more snooping

Horowhenua mayor Michael Feyen refused to vote on a new email blocking policy.

The Horowhenua District Council is changing the way it screens emails.

83-year-old dies in crash

A car and a truck crashed at an intersection in Levin.

The man died on Monday after his car collided with a truck in Levin.

Nelson

Makos legend back in the fold

Robbie Malneek last played for the Tasman Makos during the 2015 Mitre 10 Cup season.

Robbie Malneek, the only player to reach 100 caps for the Tasman Makos, has been handed an unlikely recall.

Car-free summer

Kerry and Garry Ford of Ford's restaurant and bar in upper Trafalgar Street, which will become a pedestrian zone over ...

The top of Nelson's Trafalgar St is going to be traffic free for four months this summer.

Pensioner housing need

Tasman District Council-owned cottages in Wakefield.

Waiting list for Tasman council cottages outstrips number of units.

New library may cost $3.7m

The Motueka Library has long been earmarked for development.

Proposed new Motueka Library is unlikely to include a service centre.

Marlborough

Environment judge called in

Leachate run-off and ponding from grape marc dump sites in Marlborough. (File pic)

A prominent winemaker and a new company he is linked to - dubbed the "complete solution" to grape marc - are to be dealt with by the Environment Court.

'Stupid thing to do'

Blenheim District Court.

A man has admitted shooting out a window at the health hub in the central business district.

Police called to polling booth

Kaikōura Labour candidate Janette Walker delivering pamphlets at Dillons Point Rd, in Blenheim, earlier this week.

"He wanted my details. I gave him about half of them," says Kaikōura candidate as she refuses to leave.

Leap in rateable values

New capital values across Marlborough show a big increase for Picton properties. (File pic)

Some properties have seen their capital value incease by a whopping 28 per cent.

South Canterbury

Timaru's next tourism attraction?

In May a High Court Judge ruled the Rangatira be sold to pay off more than $170,000 owed to PrimePort.

Fisherman hopes community will save ship with Hollywood connection from the scrap heap.

A toast to the bicycle video

Graeme Simpson is preparing to take a collection of old bikes to Waimate to celebrate 200 years of the bicycle.

Bicycles of all shapes and sizes to be celebrated in 200th anniversary event.

Air plan approved

South Canterbury Regional Air Plan Liaison Committee chairman Mark Rogers with committee members Doug Cleveland, centre, ...

Grey Power president says it was "too much" to expect woodburner rule to be ditched.

Hatchery positive of salmon returns

Phil de Joux watches the salmon enter McKinnon Creek following incubation in July last year.

Volunteers of South Canterbury salmon hatchery hope for a better season.

Otago

Six-figure golden handshake

Aurora Energy boss Grady Cameron's exit package means he will make nearly $1 million in a year.

Otago lines company boss's 'excessive' exit package means he'll make nearly $1m this year.

Waterfall search for man

Police are searching for missing Dunedin man Stephen Lowe.

Police divers search a Catlins waterfall and river for missing Dunedin man Stephen Lowe.

Residents unsatisfied with DQ

Blue Peaks Lodge manager Michael McMillan was appointed to the Destination Queenstown board to represent the ...

Queenstown had a four per cent increase in visitors to about 3.2 million in the 2016/17 year.

Highlanders land prop early

Tyrel Lomax played his first game for Tasman last weekend.

Son of former Kiwis league player will join Highlanders next year after Melbourne Rebels cut him loose.

Southland

Investigators baffled by child's disappearance

Amber-Lee Cruickshank, pictured age one, went missing on October 17, 1992.

Police travelled to the Australian outback looking for answers about what happened to toddler Amber-Lee Cruickshank 25 years ago.

70 years strong

John and Joan Welsh with their wedding day photo from 1947.

On September 22, John and Joan Welsh celebrated their 70th wedding anniversary.

Trust announces it will seek review

Community Trust of Southland chair Margot Hishon

The Community Trust of Southland will seek a ministerial review into the circumstances surrounding the departure of its former chief executive. 

Bluff signpost: It's a bluff

Scottish tourist Geoff Mumford tries to make sense of Bluff's suspect signpost.

Handy hint: Don't follow the famous signpost's directions to Wellington. 

Ad Feedback