Report finds safety testing flaws before tuk-tuk crash that injured six people in Wellington

The report into a tuk-tuk crash in Wellington in December, which injured six people, shows the canopy collapsed on ...
SUPPLIED

The report into a tuk-tuk crash in Wellington in December, which injured six people, shows the canopy collapsed on impact, endangering passengers.

A report into a tuk-tuk crash in Wellington late last year has revealed safety testing flaws put passengers at risk, and probably led to the injuries suffered by six people on board.

The $30,000 investigation into the crash, on Wellington's steep and winding Roseneath Tce in December, was commissioned by the New Zealand Transport Agency after its inspection of the tuk-tuk following the incident raised concerns about its stability and "rollover" strength.

According to the report, obtained under the Official Information Act, five passengers suffered head and facial injuries in the accident, including concussion, cuts and bruises, which required emergency medical care or hospital treatment.

The front right side of the tuk-tuk was significantly damaged.
SUPPLIED

The front right side of the tuk-tuk was significantly damaged.

The report says the vehicle's metal canopy offered "little to no resistance" to the crash, and its supporting pillars also failed to withstand the impact.

READ MORE:
Tuk-tuk licences revoked after Wellington crash investigation
Tuk-tuk tours on hold after crash injures six
Tuk-tuk rolls in Roseneath hills

Tuk-tuks were certified as passenger service vehicles in September, and operated in Wellington and Auckland until they were taken off the roads in February.

The toppled tuk-tuk at the crash scene, in Roseneath Tce, Wellington.
SUPPLIED

The toppled tuk-tuk at the crash scene, in Roseneath Tce, Wellington.

The report, signed off in January, shows the vehicles were incorrectly given safety certificates and, had the issues been addressed, "the level of injuries would likely have been reduced".

"The condition of the vehicle does not meet the expected behaviour of a rollover frame; the vehicle structure has failed to provide reasonable protection to occupants."

WHY WERE TUK-TUKS INCORRECTLY CERTIFIED?

The canopy was not able to withstand the impact of the crash, instead buckling and collapsing.
SUPPLIED

The canopy was not able to withstand the impact of the crash, instead buckling and collapsing.

NZTA hired Palmerston North-based company Sandbox Consulting to investigate the tuk-tuk's performance in the crash and, subsequently, to recommend design changes to improve the vehicles' stability.

Ad Feedback

According to the report, the error occurred because shortcuts were taken during safety testing that deemed the tuk-tuks to be roadworthy.

NZTA rules require a passenger service vehicle to be able to withstand an impact, at its highest corner, of half its maximum weight from side-on and total unladen weight from above, without sustaining permanent damage.

Police officers tend to injured occupants of the tuk-tuk. Skid marks can also be seen on the road.
SUPPLIED

Police officers tend to injured occupants of the tuk-tuk. Skid marks can also be seen on the road.

The independent engineer who issued the safety certificates for the vehicles operated in Wellington by Tuk Tuk Cartel erred by assuming the three-wheeled tuk-tuks would absorb the impact in the same way as heavy vehicles, such as buses, the report says.

The incorrect method was used for "expediency", when a separate analysis should have been carried out.

Unlike a heavy vehicle, the tuk-tuks would be unlikely to evenly distribute the force of any impact, making the front more vulnerable should it hit the ground and potentially "leading to failure".

The report also finds the steel canopy did not qualify as a rigid structure, as is assumed of heavy vehicles.

The police serious crash unit investigated the accident and deemed neither the driver nor Tuk Tuk Cartel was at fault.

Glen Varcoe, who set up Tuk Tuk Cartel with his brother Jeremy Marr, said the report appeared "interesting", and he would take a couple of days to consider it before commenting further.

NZTA said on Monday that the independent engineer involved was currently being investigated by the Institution of Professional Engineers.

He was issuing safety certificates as "a suitable qualified person", an NZTA spokeswoman said, but was not an NZTA appointee.

"Because there is an ongoing investigation, the Transport Agency is not able to comment on the circumstances that resulted in the vehicles being deemed compliant with PSV requirements.

"All Transport Agency-appointed independent vehicle certifiers are subject to performance monitoring and auditing by the agency with respect to certifications carried out under those appointments."

She added: "The process used for certifying the vehicles as passenger service vehicles was the correct one, but the crash investigation by the NZTA has indicated that the vehicles did not comply with the relevant technical requirements of the passenger service vehicle rule."

WHAT NOW?

New testing criteria has been introduced to assess the stability of three-wheeled vehicles before they are issued with a certificate of fitness.

The testing will ensure "real-world stability" similar to that of a four-wheeled vehicle, and includes a raft of engineering calculations. 

It was unclear whether the necessary improvements could be made to tuk-tuks to bring them to an acceptable safety level, the report said.

NZTA said it was up to tuk-tuk operators to decide if they wanted to reapply for an operating licence if and when they were deemed roadworthy.

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Northland crash kills one

Emergency services were called just after 3.30am to the accident south of Whangarei.

One person has died in an accident early on Saturday morning south of Whangarei.

How do you stop begging? video

Marcus Pohio is homeless and regularly begs on Courtenay Place, in Wellington.

The only thing that will get Marcus Pohio off the street is death. But is public generosity speeding that up?

A day in the life of Jackie van Beek

Jackie van Beek and her husband Jesse Griffin.

Each week we ask a famous New Zealander to share a photo memory.

Woman gives birth at shopping mall

The baby was rushed to Starship Hospital in critical condition after it was born at Sylvia Park mall. (File photo)

A baby has been born in the toilets of an Auckland mall and rushed to hospital with its mum, in critical condition.

Wellington

Ex-cop battles police to save RSA

Former Titahi Bay RSA president John Ward.

An alcohol sting on the Titahi Bay RSA was excessive, and could have shut the club permanently, he says.

Night of wind, rain video

Heavy rain is set to ease into showers, but they'll be heavy. (File photo)

Almost 13mm of rain is forecast in Wellington between now and midnight.

100 powerless on East Coast

Power has been lost to about 100 people on the North Island's East Coast. (File photo)

Storms cause several major faults as trees fall on to power lines.

Seatbelt message fails to click video

Freezing worker Danielle Kiriau, 17, was not wearing a seatbelt when she died in a car crash along with brother Shannon ...

Big rise in numbers killed when not wearing belts raises questions over safety ads.

Canterbury

The Bain story - one more time

Martin van Beynen, veteran print journo and now a podcaster, has been following the Bain case for 20 years.

Investigation culminates in major new true crime podcast about controversial murders.

Live: Southern deluge 

The Temuka River creeps higher and higher after a day of rain caused havoc around the South Island.

State of emergencies declared in several areas as flood waters force scores of evacuations.

Unborn baby dies after crash

A woman's baby was stillborn after she was in a two-car crash at this intersection of Ashley Gorge Rd and German Rd, ...

A heavily pregnant Canterbury woman's unborn child has died after a head-on car crash.

Second meth clean-up at complex

The Housing NZ Gloucester St unit being decontaminated for methamphetamine has been stripped of carpet.

HNZ's tenancy management negligence creates "ghetto-like environment", resident says.

Waikato

Honeymoon hoon's 202kmh ticket

Brazilian surgeon Marco Filho, adjusting his belt after leaving the Hamilton courthouse on Friday, was charged with ...

Safe to say the Brazilian speedster is not in the good books of his new wife.

'Slow the (truck) down'

A variable speed limit for the section of Gordonton Road could be in place within a couple of months, council's ...

Frustrated city councillors send a message to drivers at a troublesome intersection.

Motorcyclist critical after crash

The crash occurred at the corner of the intersection of the Thermal Explorer Highway and Anzac St East in Horotiu.

Man taken to hospital following a serious crash in the Waikato.

Hung jury in rape trial

A former church youth group leader has been on trial in the Hamilton District Court on a raft of rape and sexual assault ...

A jury has been unable to determine whether a former church youth group leader raped two underage girls.

Taranaki

Truck blocks highway

The trailer of a large truck has rolled and was blocking half of SH3 near Waitotara in Taranaki on Friday.

One lane was blocked on SH3 near Waitotara after a truck crash on Friday morning.

Pre-nup was unfair

The High Court has upheld a lower court decision for a couple to equal property shares after separating

A pre-nuptial agreement gave one partner $20,000, and the other partner $1.5 million worth of assets.

Contented in Tikorangi

The cave had mysterious myths abut it but turned out to be a simple earth-moving creation.

This garden is a treasure as are the people who created it.

Doing the dirtiest work

After Disaster owner James Nunes-Vaz has never ever turned down a cleaning  job.

After the police and fire brigade have done their jobs at an emergency scene, the clean-up begins.

Manawatu

No way in, no way out video

The trail's reconstruction has made life much easier for villagers.

After the 2015 quake, villagers in Uhiya, Nepal, were isolated, forced to fend for themselves.

Paediatrician jailed

Jonathan Walsh is in jail after pleading guilty to 17 charges relating to the making and distributing of indecent images ...

Paediatrician who worked in New Zealand hospitals jailed in the UK over indecent images of children.

Petition calls for heads to roll

Horowhenua District Council chief executive David Clapperton, left, and mayor Michael Feyen are deeply divided over ...

Boss of snooping council and deputy mayor must go, says petition organiser.

Tennis courts for sale

Feilding's four asphalt courts will be sold despite five submissions opposing the sale.

Feilding's four asphalt courts will be sold despite strong opposition.

Nelson

Battle to return soldier's diary

Margaret Kearns of Stoke, Nelson with a copy of her father's dairy, Hartley Palmer.

The Government has intervened to help return a war diary to its rightful home in Nelson.

Nelson's changing face

La Per and Mu Su Pan say they enjoy living in Nelson.

A fifth of Nelson's population was born overseas. Can the city meet their needs?

The making of Jack Bauer video

A shattered Jack Bauer reacts after the finish as he was caught by the peloton just metres short of a famous stage ...

Tracing the career of Tour de France cyclist Jack Bauer back to where it all started - Golden Bay.

St Arnaud's alpine magic

Mid-winter kayaking with girls having fun on Lake Rotoiti.

Anyone who has ever spent any time at the alpine village of St Arnaud, Lake Rotoiti, will already know what a special place it is. 

Marlborough

All hands on deck

John's Kitchen supervisor Richard McDonald likes the idea that food can be an expression of care.

Blenheim charity kitchen takes on new staff to cope with high workload.

The next big quake

The Adelphi Hotel, in Kaikoura, was pulled down due to earthquake damage.

It's impossible to say when an earthquake is going to strike. But the predictable patterns of aftershocks can help.

Exploring Africa

The Hansby family at Victoria Falls, from left, Luke Hansby, Fleur Hansby, Nick Hansby and Sam Hansby.

When you plan your trip to Africa, the animals and environment are expected to be the main attraction.

Dream team

Hundreds of Marlborough children took part in the first ever Sir Peter Blake Trust Dream Bank survey.

Kind-hearted children have aspirations to help protect the planet and conserve natural heritage.

South Canterbury

Army called in to help gallery video

BP on Evans St, Timaru, has flooded.

Timaru and Oamaru in state of emergency as rain continues to fall. 

Downpours strike  video

Water rushes under the Leith Footbridge, in Dunedin, about 11pm on Friday.

Storm sweeps south as Timaru placed under state of emergency.

Army to evacuate sick child

An aerial view of an Oamaru street that has surface flooding in what was Oamaru's wettest day in July on record.

Defence Force sends truck to Oamaru to transport sick child to Dunedin.

Fallen tree blocks driveway

Timaru resident Ricky Hunter with a tree that fell across his driveway during the heavy rain on Friday, July 21.

South Canterbury man "stuck" at home with no way out other than on foot, after tree falls.

Southland

Stewart Island heritage gets $1m

An artist's impression of the Rakiura Heritage Centre. The centre has received, over $1 million in Government funding to ...

The Government is to commit $1.08m to the Rakiura Heritage Centre Trust.

Post-funeral brawl

Police and ambulance were alerted to the incident, but were not eventually required.

A post-funeral gathering in Bluff on Thursday night ended with blood, broken glass and a visit from the police.

Irrigation scheme 'a win-win'

Dairy Creek Ltd director Tim O'Sullivan, Pioneer Energy chief executive Fraser Jonker and Pioneer Energy project manager ...

A $10m irrigation scheme near Alexandra, Central Otago, is going to deliver water to about 1800 hectares of barren land.

Gecko stolen from visitor centre

The Marlborough green gecko that was stolen from the Fiordland National Park Visitor Centre in Te Anau.

An at risk gecko has been stolen from the DoC visitor centre in Fiordland.

Ad Feedback