Record number of insanity verdicts in New Zealand courts

Last year, five people charged with murder were found not guilty due to insanity. That included Tevito Filo, the man who ...
DAVID WHITE/STUFF

Last year, five people charged with murder were found not guilty due to insanity. That included Tevito Filo, the man who viciously attacked Auckland woman Jo Pert while she was running in Remuera.

A record number of Kiwis were found not guilty by reason of insanity in New Zealand courts last year. 

The figures released under the Official Information Act show the defence was successfully used by 34 people in 2016, compared with just four in 2000. 

The reason behind the rise is unclear, but Health and Disability Commissioner Anthony Hill has urged caution about drawing conclusions around the increase. 

Victim Jo Pert, whose killer was found not guilty by reason of insanity.
SUPPLIED

Victim Jo Pert, whose killer was found not guilty by reason of insanity.

"What we know through studies in New Zealand and overseas is that serious offences by people with mental illness can and do occur, but are very rare," Hill said. 

READ MORE:
* The dementia defence 
Questions over woman's care
Man who stabbed stranger had killed brother 13 years earlier
The tragic and violent case of Richard Hawkins
Insane killers need closer monitoring

In 2016, over 77,000 adults were prosecuted in court, and nearly 13,000 were not convicted for various reasons, including those found not guilty by reason of insanity, Hill said. 

Shaun Robinson, head of the Mental Health Foundation.
CHRIS SKELTON/STUFF

Shaun Robinson, head of the Mental Health Foundation.

"Exaggerated fear about people with mental illness committing offences generates unfair and damaging stigma and discrimination." 

Last year, five people charged with murder were found not guilty due to insanity. That included Tevito Filo, 25, the man who viciously attacked and murdered Auckland woman Jo Pert while she was running in Remuera. 

It is a judge who usually decides if someone is legally insane based on medical evidence provided by the Crown and defence. Due to legislative changes in 2003, a person is typically deemed insane prior to going to trial. 

Those found insane can be admitted as a special patient and placed in the care of a forensic unit for an indefinite period of time. 

Ad Feedback

Victim advocate Ruth Money said it was important for seriously ill people to be rehabilitated in the right way, but the term "not guilty" was wrong. 

"The whole not guilty by reason of insanity verdict does not deliver justice for the victim. It may be a legal definition, but it is very offensive to tell that offender they are not guilty." 

Mental health foundation CEO Shaun Robinson agreed with Money the language around insanity needed to change.

Robinson pointed out there is already a large number of people with mental health issues currently in prison.

Being able to care and rehabilitate offenders with severe mental health issues was vital to having a safer community, he said. 

"Most importantly forensic services are there to support a person to recover, to participate and be part of the community when they are released. Statistics show this works far better than an ordinary prison situation." 

The overall number of people found unfit to stand trial also increased from 126 in 2015 to 145 last year. 

 - Sunday Star Times

Comments

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Holiday weekend's deadly start

Traffic heading south out Auckland will test weekenders' patience. And the roadworks don't help.

One killed in crash near Turangi, bringing the Labour Weekend death toll to three.

Cyclist hospitalised after crash

The crash happened on Tamaki Drive, near the intersection with Long Drive, in St Heliers.

 A person has sustained serious injuries after an incident on a popular Auckland cycle route.

Actor's son reunited with iPad

Shane Cortese and his son were intimidated and robbed on a train.

Shane Cortese was travelling with his son on an Auckland train when they were robbed.

Stabbing leaves man in critical condition

A woman has been charged after a man was stabbed on Auckland's North Shore.

A 21-year-old man has been taken to Auckland Hospital after being stabbed at at a property in Browns Bay.

Wellington

Popular mini-train returns

The Aotea Lagoon train was decommissioned two years ago, but Porirua City Council project manager Philip Royle, left, ...

Porirua's only mini-train will get a new lease on life this Labour weekend.

Ardern's honeymoon video

Jacinda Ardern needs to own the narrative for the next three years.

OPINION: After a month in limbo and playing second fiddle to Winston Peters, Jacinda Ardern gets moving.

Lions too tough for Taniwha

Jackson Garden-Bachop, left, and Julian Savea were to the fore as Wellington played their way into Friday's championship ...

Wellington impress in comfortable championship semifinal win over Northland.

 The Campaigner

12-09-17 Fairfax Media Picture by David White 
Evangelia "Van" Henderson, CEO of Breast Cancer Foundation

When Evangelia Henderson was first touched by breast cancer, she was too young to understand. Now, she won't stop fighting it.

Canterbury

Where the flip are penguins? video

White-flippered penguins at Harris Bay, Banks Peninsula.

Row over local baches holding up white-flippered penguin colony near Christchurch - 20 years on.

Rail collapse injures 4

Four men were on the deck outside the Portage Resort Hotel's restaurant and bar in the Marlborough Sounds when a rail ...

Men injured, one seriously, after railing on deck they were standing on collapsed at a Marlborough Sounds hotel.

Woman dies in single-car crash 

Jaimey Leigh Fellows, who was killed in a car crash overnight, has been remembered as a funny and genuine woman who ...

Jaimey Leigh Fellows, 32, died in single vehicle crash near Burnham overnight.

Stranger threatens young woman

Police said a man in a black four-wheel-drive with tinted windows approached the woman in Shirley and threatened her.

Man in a 4WD with tinted windows threatened the walker, told her to get in his car.

Waikato

Recognise this guy? 

Recognise this guy? The police want to hear from you if you do.

Police have released images of one of the suspected robbers of a Belgian hitchhiker.

Crash snarls traffic

Traffic's at a crawl around Huntly (file photo).

A fender bender on SH1 has brought southbound traffic to a stop.

Domino's robbed

Police are investigating a robbery at a Domino's pizza shop in Hamilton.

Armed pair each wore a balaclava and a hoodie. They escaped in a waiting car driven by a third person.

Mad moggies

Repetitive meowing, licking themselves too much, pacing and even chasing their tails can all be signs of obsessive ...

Obsessive compulsive disorder ... cats get it, too.

Taranaki

Losing its 'life blood'

19102017 News Photo ANDY JACKSON/STUFF.   Graeme Duckett for feature on the old AFCO freezing works in Waitara.

Known as the "university" it was the training ground for a crop of freezing workers who pumped money and life into Waitara.

Bringing South Africa to Taranaki

Wim Jansen with the home-made biltong.

The South African community in New Plymouth will now have access to the tastes of home.

 Farm bikers injured 

Two people were injured in a farm bike accident in Taranaki

Two people were admitted to Taranaki Base Hospital with injuries from riding farm bikes

Stratford's $292k surplus 

The overall net value of the Stratford District Council rose from $303.9m to $316.5m during the year.

After spending $16.4m last year, Stratford's council had $292,000 left over.

Manawatu

Practical magic video

The tools of furniture maker Rowan Dicks' trade.

Rowan Dicks makes furniture that isn't just run-of-the-mill.

Principal's full-time siren sounds

Retired Manchester St School principal Rex Wheeler has more time to spend reconditioning his 1937 Studebaker Gran ...

After 43 years in the district, principal Rex Wheeler has more time for tinkering.

Angst over digital plan

GENERIC e-learning, 23 July 2004. AFR Picture by GABRIELE CHAROTTE


students internet computer web learning

A new digital curriculum awaits New Zealand schools. But who's teaching the teachers?

Flying Doctor's new book

Dave Baldwin believes people became a true healthy bastard if they attend to their physical, mental and spiritual sides.

Dave Baldwin has published the third book of his Healthy Bastards campaign.   

Nelson

Makos fans jet into enemy territory

Originair flight OG3313 Captain Warwick Wild shows his support for the Tasman Makos before a flight to New Plymouth today.

Look out Ferdinand - there'll be a few more fins up in the crowd at Yarrow Stadium this weekend.

Tale of two MPs

Nick Smith says National will be a formidable force in opposition.

The top of the south looks set to swap one cabinet minister for another.

Hotel deck rail collapse injures

Four men were on the deck outside the Portage Resort Hotel's restaurant and bar in the Marlborough Sounds when a rail ...

Four men injured, one seriously, after railing on deck they were standing on collapsed at Marlborough Sounds hotel.

Salisbury takes heart 

Salisbury School at Richmond is the only national single-sex residential school for girls with intellectual disabilities.

Could the long fight to save Salisbury School be over with the change of government?

Marlborough

Hotel deck rail collapse injures

Four men were on the deck outside the Portage Resort Hotel's restaurant and bar in the Marlborough Sounds when a rail ...

Four men injured, one seriously, after railing on deck they were standing on collapsed at Marlborough Sounds hotel.

SH1 rebuild continues

Work at Ohau point on State Highway 1 on Thursday. The site is one of the critical parts of the rebuild.

Night-time closures, unsealed sections and lane closures will greet travellers when quake-damaged SH1 reopens.

Tiny train turns 50 video

Picton Society of Model Engineers members, from left, Brian Henstock, Kerry Johnson and Graham Low get the train ready ...

What a difference 50 years makes? Ten cents of a difference in fact.

All the fun of the fair

Hannah Schmitt and Scarlet Venrooy had a great time on the trailer ride last year.

The Linkwater School Spring Fair is on today, right on time to plant up your vegetable garden.

South Canterbury

It's coming down

Owner of the Hydro Grand, Allan Booth.

Timaru's Hydro Grand Hotel could be reduced to rubble by the end of November.

Disease 'contained'

22092017 News Photo: TOM LEE/STUFF - Dairy Cow, Farming, Fonterra, Cattle. Milking, Dawn Morning.

Ministry for Primary Industries confident Mycoplasma bovis is contained.

'Cautious optimism'

Federated Farmers South Canterbury chairman Mark Adams.

Hopes and fears have been raised by prominent South Canterbury figures now our new Government has been revealed.

Farewell to commissioner

Fairlie Primary School commissioner Terri Johnstone has said farewell to the school.

Fairlie Primary School is in a state of self-governence once more.

Otago

Fire rages near Te Anau

A large scrub fire covering more than 1300 hectares started at Mt Prospect Station near Te Anau.

Six helicopters are helping fight an out-of-control Southland blaze that's spread to more than 1300 hectares.

Boy seriously hurt in crash

A rescue helicopter lands at the crash site.

The long weekend is off to a bad start in the South Island, with a three-vehicle crash leaving a boy with serious injuries.

New plan to create affordable homes

Members of the Queenstown Lakes Mayoral Housing Affordability Taskforce presenting their recommendations: chairman John ...

Restrictions could be placed on Airbnb-type short-term rentals for visitors.

Joint approach trialed to freedom camping enforcement in the Catlins

Freedom camping will be more heavily monitored in the Catlins over summer, with a jointly-funded approach to be trialed ...

Otago-Southland authorities join forces to control freedom camping in the Catlins.

Southland

Fire rages near Te Anau

A large scrub fire covering more than 1300 hectares started at Mt Prospect Station near Te Anau.

Six helicopters helping fight out-of-control blaze that's spread to more than 1300 hectares.

Fishing for all

Greg Sheppard, from Te Anau's, Trout Observatory releases a rainbow trout into McGregor's Pond near Te Anau, under the ...

Southerners are spoilt for choice this weekend in terms of things to do.

Southland fraudster sentenced

The Invercargill District Court.

A Southland fraudster who admitted 16 dishonesty charges has been sentenced to community detention.

A passion for the immortal Mustang

Wayne Fabish, of the Taranaki Mustang Club, spent four years building up his 67 Mustang, which he is showing for the ...

The 38th National Mustang Convention taking place in Invercargill this weekend.

Ad Feedback