Victims of pyramid scheme demand their money back


Fran Halford of Nelson talks about why she is speaking out about Circle.

Women who lost thousands of dollars to illegal pyramid schemes promising enlightenment and sisterhood are demanding their money back.

As the truth about the gifting circles becomes known, those who have been involved are speaking out despite being ostracised for it.

Nelson woman Clare Halford, formerly known as Fran, said she recently contacted the ex-leader of a circle she was involved in to say she wanted to be paid back the $5000 US ($7000 NZ) she gave her to join. 

Clare Halford wants to get her money back after she was involved in a women's gifting circle.
Braden Fastier/Stuff

Clare Halford wants to get her money back after she was involved in a women's gifting circle.

"I got a bit more feisty this time and said it was not okay. Last night she put $3000 in my bank account and said we should meet and talk about the rest she owes me."

She still hopes to get the $4000 outstanding.

* Spiritually transmitted disease: The poison lotus
High-flying women lose money in secret spiritual movement with 'hallmarks of pyramid scheme'
'Naive' investors claim $650,000 lost to suspected Ponzi​
Is Herbalife a pyramid scheme? Billionaires at odds over the question

The Commerce Commission last month announced women's gifting circles are illegal pyramid schemes in breach of the Fair Trading Act, after it launched an investigation last year.

Women operating a circle, or who invite others to join one, may be fined up to $600,000 per offence.

Kattia Wong is encouraging other women to ask for their money back that they gifted in illegal pyramid schemes.
David White/Stuff

Kattia Wong is encouraging other women to ask for their money back that they gifted in illegal pyramid schemes.

A former medical doctor turned writer, Halford went public last year as part of a three month investigation by journalist Anke Richter.

She was "hunted down" by two respected, professional women from the Nelson community and recruited.

They met as a circle every week to discuss life, spirituality and development, and had a weekly conference call with one other woman and coaching on how to recruit others.

But it wasn't long before she discovered the "box of chocolates was actually a box of curds".

Ad Feedback

"It's really so unbelievable I fell for it — but that's what's so insidious about it. The women were really lovely professionals who I respected and admired."

Originating in the United States and Bali, many circles have been set up in Auckland, Tauranga, Nelson and Golden Bay over the last few years.

Gifting circles are illegal in Canada and in the US have been under investigation by the FBI where more than 20 circle women have been convicted for fraud and tax evasion and two given a 14-year jail sentence.

There is no website, no registered organisation, just "friends telling friends" who claim their actions are legal because you can privately gift money in New Zealand up to any amount.


Leaders invite women to make a one-off gift of NZ$7000, in return for sacred sisterhood, empowerment and abundance.

They sign a document stating it's a "gift and not an investment" and that they "expect nothing in return" and cannot ask for it back.

Women enter the circle as a Seed, then move on to Sapling, then Blossom and finally achieve the "Lotus" status to receive a cash gift of $56,000 NZ from eight new women. If they are unable to recruit others the group can collapse. 

Only about 12 per cent of women ever make a profit and the rest lose their money.

A "circle invitation training" document from Bali in 2014 tells members to be very "private" about the circles and "discerning" about who they invite.

They are not to talk about circles in public places, to keep all circle documents in a private place, to not invite women in the legal professions and to invite women only by telephone or in person — but never by email.

Halford is part of a Facebook support group for mainly New Zealand women who have left circles, called the Muddy Lotus, with nearly 100 members.

She is encouraging other women to ask for their money back too.

"Many women feel a lot of shame and embarrassment for being involved so they don't ask. Others don't want to lose friends in the community. Also because it was a gift, some women feel like they can't get it back."

Auckland fashion designer Kattia Wong was also paid back her money by an "experienced sister" from another circle, but not her ex-Lotus.

"When I realised what circle was really about I spoke out and I was on the front of a newspaper and national radio, that's when I got my money back. They wanted me to shut up."

Circles were "breaking apart communities of women" and praying on their loneliness and vulnerability, who were losing thousands of dollars to a few at the top.

Women should not feel they are not doing anything wrong by asking for their money back – that it's their right.

"When they recruit you they make you sign a document saying that you are not expecting anything in return. This is the main reason women don't ask for their money back, but they need to understand this whole thing is illegal and the document didn't mean anything anyway." 

It was "like a thief selling stolen goods", Wong said.

One Golden Bay woman, who did not want to be named, lost all her money but says she has no regrets.

She was involved in two circles over three years and she gifted $7000 to her Lotus, which she took out of her mortgage.

She said she got "so much in the way of growth and love" and felt only positive about the "genuine women" and intention of the group and never felt like a victim.

Another Golden Bay woman said the local circles made her sad because it "isn't what women supporting women should be about".

She really believed women supporting each other in a "true circle" without monetary gain could bring lasting positive change.

"But when I see something like this happen in Golden Bay, where it's getting really catty and messy and pulling people apart, it makes me sad."



Ad Feedback
special offers

Long knockout cup journey

Glenfield defender Tessa Berger won the Women's Knockout Cup with Forrest Hill Milford last year.

To get to their Women's Knockout Cup tie in Dunedin on Saturday, an Auckland club is leaving on Friday afternoon, and travelling via Christchurch.

Playground under repairs

Residents ask why the playground is blocked off.

Orewa playground set to reopen next week.

Record breaking cocaine bust

Augustine Suarez-Juarez and Ronald Cook in the High Court at Auckland, where they faced charges of importing, possession ...

Smuggler called the ''Technician'' and right hand man jailed after smuggling 35kgs of cocaine into NZ in a diamante-encrusted horse sculpture.

New principal working collaboratively

Robin Kirkham is the new principal at Point View School in Dannemora, East Auckland.

Robin Kirkham, the third principal of an East Auckland primary, brings overseas experience and methods to his new job.


Giving the gift of movement

Wheels 4 Life was founded in 2005 with the aim of providing bicycles to people in Third World countries in need of ...

A Wellington mountain biker is helping provide a transport lifeline for some of the poorest children.

110kmh for highways

A 110kmh speed limit on some roads will be in place by the end of the year. Digitally altered photograph.

Speed limits on select highways will be raised to 110kmh by the end of the year, Government announces.

Cellmate tells of  murder plot

Former Hawke's Bay man Peter Beckett is on trial in Canada for the second time charged with the murder of his wife.

Former councillor accused of murder tried to have wife's family killed, Canadian court hears.

Is NZ's drug policy Dunne for good?

Peter Dunne became the political face of drug reform during his time in Parliament.

OPINION: Sensible and drugs. Two words that used to be unlikely bedfellows. Yet with Peter Dunne, that is exactly what you got.


Life with five kids five and under video

Raising five young children is equally terrifying and rewarding for Christchurch parents.

Christchurch parents of newborn triplets face 24 nappy changes and 24 feeds a day.

Cash for new stadium

Christchurch's proposed multi-use arena could have a steel roof and a retractable turf.

National pledges extra $120m for new Christchurch stadium on top of $59m already committed.

$35.7m park development approved

Denton Park supporters make their views seen and heard during a contentious Christchurch City Council decision to build ...

Build at Denton Park breaches wishes of the man who gifted the land, his family says.

Teen jailed after two police chases

A second set of road spikes were laid, so Ethan Stuart Batt, 19, drove on the wrong side of the road, forcing other road ...

Road spikes were laid, so the teen drove on the wrong side, forcing drivers to swerve.


New theatre unveiled

An artist's impression of what the new Waikato regional theatre could look like from the river. Full designs are still ...

The Waikato's new theatre may also house an art gallery and a hotel.

110kmh limit coming

A 110kmh speed limit on some roads will be in place by the end of the year. Digitally altered photograph.

Speed limits on Waikato expressway will be raised to 110kmh by the end of the year, Government says.

Our cold house shame

House designed by Solarei architecture and design practice, using passive solar design principles.

They're killing us yet many homes are still designed for 4pm on a summer's day.

Man falls down Hakarimata stairs

The Hakarimata stairs is a popular walking/ running track in Ngaruawahia (file photo).

The man suffered multiple injuries and was flown to Waikato Hospital.


Eaton brawl allegation

Former All Black Jason Eaton.

Former All Blacks lock Jason Eaton linked to early morning assault in France.

Camping consultation

The New Plymouth District Council voted to give ratepayers a say on freedom campers.

The public will get to have their say on whether freedom campers should be allowed in New Plymouth.

Charge against Keenan withdrawn 

A single theft charge against a former police officer was withdrawn in the New Plymouth District Court on Thursday, but ...

A former hapu chief executive is likely to face more charges, but for now his time in court is over.

Z Hawera robbed again

Police at the Z Petrol Station in Hawera following a robbery in the early hours of Thursday, August 24.

The Z in Hawera has been robbed ovenight for the second time in two months.


Kind Hearts spreading

Central Normal pupils Ngamarama Tuariki, 10, Nevaeh Anihana, 11, and Calais Parkinson, 10, learning about being Kind Hearts.

Winter chills are being chased away, with an explosion of warmheartedness hitting schools.

Candidates face off

Grey Power members listen to candidates for Palmerston North pitch for votes.

Law and order to the fore at candidates debate in Palmerston North.

Guns found at gang house

Reports of slug-gun fire from an Opie Pl, Highbury, property led to a police raid that turned up a cache of guns.

Police raided a Highbury house after occupants took potshots at neighbouring properties.

Water tower sold

The tower and pump shed are all that remain of the old Lake Alice Psychiatric Hospital.

It took only about 10 days for the Lake Alice water tower to sell.


Therapy an adventure

Richard Wilkins, pictured here at Whenua Iti, is organising the first adventure therapy course in Nelson.

Can "adventure therapy", immersive courses in the great outdoors, help troubled youth?

Pooch poo pollution

Littered dog waste is not just a nuisance but also an environmental hazard.

Lazy owners not picking up dog poo isn't just an eyesore, it's affecting Nelson's waterways.

Candidates front up

Forum chairwoman Judene Edgar, right, introduces the candidates, from left, Nick Smith, Sue Sara, Rachel Boyack, Richard ...

Election hopeful answer questions from Nelson's volunteer and community sector.

Rough sleeping banned

People like Peter Wilkie, left,  will no longer be able to sleep rough overnight in the Nelson CBD.

Nelson City Council bylaw puts in place ban on rough sleeping in city centre.


Teen's three-week meter raid

Dozens of parking meters in Blenheim were vandalised in May. (File photo)

He pried open the parking meters with a screwdriver, returning several times at night as they filled up again.

Victims' stories

Lara Glover, 16, died and four others were injured in the car crash on February 19.

The crash killed one but affected many, and some of those affected want to speak at the driver's sentencing.

Vineyards: Investment with 'sex appeal'

Misty Cove founder Andrew Bailey is selling a vineyard the company co-owns with Moa founder Josh Scott in Onamalutu, ...

It's like any commercial investment really, except you get to say you own a vineyard.

Duck hunter's maimai meltdown

Hunters use maimais during duck shooting season. (File photo)

Enraged man caught illegally hunting tells female ranger she should be at home looking after the children.

South Canterbury

Eyeing up Nashville

Kaylee Bell will release her latest single Next Somebody on Friday, September 1.

Kiwi country pop singer/songwriter Kaylee Bell returns from Nashville to release new single.

$1.5m roading fix

South Canterbury Councils are looking to foot an estimated $1.5 million bill to fix roading damage due to July's deluge, ...

South Canterbury's councils face a $1.5 million clean-up bill for July's floods.

Evans St traffic monitoring video

23082017  News JOHN BISSET/STUFF.    Timaru Engravers and Giftware owner Ewen Lawson is sick and tired of heavy trucks ...

A mobile camera unit on Timaru's busy main road road would record the number of speeding cars.

Truck rolls on Evans St

A police spokewoman said it was understood the driver of this truck swerved to avoid another motorist before rolling on ...

SH1 is closed after a truck rolled as it swerved to avoid a aother vehicle in Timaru.


Young schoolgirl attacked

Cromwell College.

A 10-year-old Cromwell girl was punched and taunted for looking like a boy by high school girls who then posted a video of the attack online.

Bain murders movie planned

David Bain leaves Dunedin police station under police escort in 1994, on his way to court to be charged with the murders ...

The film, currently titled 65 Every Street, will focus on the Bain family and events leading up to their 1994 murders.

Disgraced cop quits

Former police officer Jeremy Buis sent anonymous text messages featuring gay slurs and photos of penises.

Constable who waged two-year harassment campaign against Dunedin man resigns, with police labelling his actions "disgraceful".

No pool for school

Wakatipu High School principal Steve Hall says students will have to use the Queenstown Event Centre for swimming ...

Wakatipu High School principal is disappointed the new premises won't have a swimming pool.


Celebrate being a Southlander

Sport Southland staff members, from left, Suzie Harrington, Laura Faherty, Nathan Burdon, Gareth Scott, Georgia Timpany, ...

Today is the day to embrace being a Southlander, put your purple shirt on and get behind the Ronald McDonald House and the Southland Stags.

Gore man has busy life

Sport Southland connecting communities advisor Martin Mackereth at the MLT Event Centre in Gore.

Martin Mackereth leads a busy life on and off the sports fields.

Highest rates in Southland

Gore District Council chief executive officer Stephen Parry is paid $252,535 a year.

The Gore District Council charges the highest average residential rates in Southland, at $2198 per year.

Rural-urban divide widens

Invercargill MP and National candidate, Sarah Dowie

The Invercargill MP says instead of further taxing farmers, their money should be available for innovation.

Ad Feedback