Minister's boast: Kiwi health system 'envy of the world' ... Well, yes and no

Health Minister Jonathan Coleman: "...envy of the world".

Health Minister Jonathan Coleman: "...envy of the world".

Health Minister Jonathan Coleman likes to think New Zealand's health system is the envy of the world, and even some of those people in the sector who aren't particularly impressed by the minister think he has a point.

"We do have a good health system. It compares favourably overall internationally but it has nothing to do with the leadership of this minister," Association of Salaried Medical Specialists (ASMS) executive director Ian Powell said.

"All that means is that our system is better able to function in an environment of under-funding than other systems, but that is no excuse for the level of poor leadership we have had," he said.

Ian Powell: good health system "nothing to do with the leadership of this minister".

Ian Powell: good health system "nothing to do with the leadership of this minister".

"Coleman's comment about a system to envy has nothing to do with his performance and everything to do with him latching onto a health system based on good sound principles."

'We've got a health system that's the envy of the world,' minister tells cancer charities
Terminal cancer patient priced out of life-prolonging medication
New melanoma drug gets Medsafe registration for lung cancer

Coleman made his proud boast this week at a political debate in Wellington organised by Cango - a group of nine prominent cancer charities. "If you stand back and go to the World Health Organisation, where I was two months ago, you will realise we have got a health system that's the envy of the world," he said.

Dr Chris Jackson:. systems and resources  falling behind.

Dr Chris Jackson:. systems and resources falling behind.

As far as Cango chairman Graeme Woodside is concerned, the claim is wrong when it comes to cancer.

"Our health system in general is certainly superior to that of many countries, but we are seriously lagging behind in some areas and the minister seems to be oblivious to that," Woodside said.

"Australia, for example, has had access to a number of drugs we still don't have access to and that's simply not good enough.

"People are experiencing serious delays to treatment and some are dying unnecessarily because our health system is failing them. Kiwis don't have access to the screening or treatment programmes that other countries offer and the fact that our minister doesn't seem to recognise that is concerning."

Ad Feedback

Coleman does get some support from the US-based Commonwealth Fund, which tends to focus on what's wrong with the health system in the US, but as part of doing that it looks at what is being done right elsewhere..

In a survey of the health systems of 11 wealthy countries published in July, it ranked New Zealand as fourth-equal overall, behind the UK at the top of the list, Australia in second and the Netherlands third. 

Despite that, New Zealand is in the second half of the field in three of the five areas looked at by the survey. 

We're seventh when it comes to access, which is about affordability and timeliness. We're also seventh on health care outcomes, and eighth on equity, which looks at how the system works for higher and lower-income people.

New Zealand's best performance is a second for administrative efficiency, and a third for the care process.

New Zealand Orthopaedic Association president Richard Keddell considers much about the health system is good but sees a problem with access to elective surgery for an increasing number of people who would benefit from it but aren't in the greatest need.

"There are certain parts of our health system that are certainly the envy of the world, and other parts aren't," Keddell said

"Our trauma management, our acute management is very well respected around the world. If you get bowled over on the road here you will get as good treatment as you will anywhere in the world," he said.

"Our ACC system is very highly regarded around the world. The standard of our elective surgery is very well regarded."

The way elective surgery was organised was quite fair. In theory, and to a fair extent in reality, those in the greatest need were treated first. "But there's an increasing number of people who are in that middle level who would definitely benefit from surgery, who aren't able to get it," Keddell said.

Looking at knee replacements, the rate at which they were carried out in this country was similar to that overseas.

"However a significant proportion of those in this country are done in the private sector. That's a little different to some other countries we're compared with. If you look at the number funded by the public system, then we're lower than some of the other countries in the OECD we're measured against," he said.

"That reflects we have a dual system in this country. That's one way to deal with the need."

The biggest problem was that demand was expected to increase significantly. "We need to look at innovative ways of managing that, and that's not just throwing money at it."

Arthritis New Zealand chief executive Sandra Kirby said this country's health system was not world class from the perspective of many of the 624,000 Kiwis living with arthritis.

"It's well-known there is a shortage of rheumatologists in New Zealand, for example, and access to an arthritis specialist very much depends on where you live," Kirby said.

The internationally recommended ratio was one rheumatologist for 100,000 people. In many parts of this country there were more than 200,000 people for each available specialist. Patients in New Zealand were at the end of the queue for cost-effective innovative medicines compared with other countries. Five of the latest biologic arthritis medications were not funded in this country.

Cancer Society medical director Dr Chris Jackson said New Zealand had many world class doctors, nurses and health professionals, but the systems and resources were falling behind.

"New Zealand has the highest rate of melanoma in the world, and one of the worst death rates from bowel cancer in the world," he said.

"You are more likely to survive cancer in Australia than you are in New Zealand. The gap in survival from cancer in Australia and NZ is actually widening.

"We have one type of drug funded for melanoma, Australia has three. Australia has five types of drugs for bowel cancer, we have three," Jackson said.

"You can get immune therapy for lung cancer in Australia, and you can't in New Zealand. We are behind Australia the UK, Ireland, and most of Western Europe when it comes to rolling out a bowel cancer screening programme."

The ASMS's Powell said one benefit of the New Zealand health system was that it was universal, unlike that in the US which was a "crap system with so many people denied access".

It was also unitary, unlike Australia where  "enormous rubbish" went on between the federal and state health systems, Powell said.

The district health system also had enormous pluses, with district health boards providing an integrated and coordinated approach.

"I think we probably get a better return for the health dollar than most countries, if not all, because of our structure," he said.

But despite being a good system, there were some bad outcomes. "We have had patients going blind ... through a fault of leadership right up to the top".

New Zealand's rating in the Commonwealth Fund study had to be put in perspective.

He had just returned from the UK, and that country's National Health Service, which topped the survey, was in "absolute turmoil".

"That's due to a level of under-funding much more severe than in New Zealand, and also due to a lot of ideologically driven structural change in the UK."

* Comments on this story are now closed.

 - Stuff


Ad Feedback
special offers

Girls rule at graffiti festival

Auckland-based muralist Adore (aka Emily Gardener) prepares for three days of painting at the Graffiato festival in ...

Seven of the 10 graffiti artists this year are women.

Council should butt out on smoking

The Auckland Council has signed on to a government plan to make New Zealand smokefree by 2025.

OPINION: Damien Grant does not want local government telling him what he can do to his own body.

Battle over Cissy's estate video

Cissy Chen was known for her caring and strong-willed nature.

Cissy Chen's husband, who was acquitted of her murder, is heading back to court over a multimillion-dollar estate.

800 Words' Michelle Langstone and her best mate

'At one point Caroline would refer to my relationship problems with men I was dating as "The Troubles."'

Actress Michelle Langstone and director Caroline Bell-Booth met as Drama School students.


'Reluctant' motor-racing champion

Denny Hulme developed his love of cars as a youngster working at the one and only garage in Motueka.

Our only F1 champion, Denny Hulme, took his fame in his stride.

Cop car rammed 

The driver did not stop for flashing lights.

Teen driver refused to stop for close to 35km, leading police on a lengthy chase.

Assault victim critical

A scene guard is in place at the site where a 49-year-old Napier man was assaulted early on Sunday morning.

A 49-year-old man is in a critical condition after an early-morning assault in Hawke's Bay.

'Change' for all NZ video

Labour's immigration policy survived coalition negotiations, Jacinda Ardern says.

Jacinda Ardern has revealed the new government's stance on migration, capitalism and "meaningful change".


Wanaka's rich, white growing pains

The growing Central Otago town of Wanaka, seen from Mt Roy.

Long-known as Queenstown's quieter cousin, Wanaka is experiencing huge growth. Can its charm survive the boom?

'Caring' crash victim video

Jaimey Leigh Fellows, who was killed in a car crash overnight, has been remembered as a funny and genuine woman who ...

Mum of woman who died in crash near Burnham says her daughter was "funny, lovely".

Arson suspected at Chch school

A fire has been contained at a building at Linwood North School on Saturday.

Fire at Linwood North School "absolutely devastating", being treated as suspicious.

'Whistler'-style housing for Qtown?

Members of the Queenstown Lakes Mayoral Housing Affordability Taskforce presenting their recommendations: chairman John ...

Plan for affordable housing in the resort could be based on the model from the Canadian ski town.


Stalker's decade of cyber terror video

Alice, left, and Harriet Campbell, right, have been stalked obsessively over the internet by a man in the United States ...

Harriet Campbell was 14 when she attracted the attention of the teen who would terrorise her.

Truck crashes on SH5

A logging truck has rolled about 20 minutes out of Rotorua on State Highway 5.

Logs are all over the road after the accident near Rotorua .

On the tyre-go-round

Shredding tyres into material to be burned in the concrete making industry is one option for old tyres, but it releases ...

Millions of tyres are stockpiled across New Zealand but there are few ideas about what to do with them.

Girls rule at graffiti festival

Auckland-based muralist Adore (aka Emily Gardener) prepares for three days of painting at the Graffiato festival in ...

Seven of the 10 street artists at theTaupō festival this year are women.


From trio of crashes to triathlon

Steve Webber and wife Louisa are off to the World Xterra Championships later this month.

He's broken his back, collarbone and his ribs twice, but now he's back on his bike at a world championship level.

Losing its 'life blood'

Graeme Duckett was one of 600 people who were made redundant from the freezing works in 1989.

Known as the "university" it was the training ground for a crop of freezing workers who pumped money and life into Waitara.

Food dream blossoming

Liz Buttimore and partner Bradley Hornby have worked together for twelve years.

A Taranaki girl's long-held dream has come to fruition in Marlborough, creating innovative food with local produce.

Titokowaru never lost his mana

This oil painting by James Barry in 1820 shows chiefs Waikato and Hongi Hika with missionary Thomas Kendall in England  ...

OPINION: History can twist a story - and besmirch the name of a great New Zealander.


Fireworks and your furry friends

Fireworks are great to look at, but the noise and lights can be terrifying for pets.

PAWS AND CLAWS: Guy Fawkes can be a terrifying experience for our pets.

Practical magic video

The tools of furniture maker Rowan Dicks' trade.

Rowan Dicks makes furniture that isn't just run-of-the-mill.

Men, money and moving on

Inbar Lavi plays serial con artist Maddie in Imposters.

OPINION: I have this vivid memory of Basil Fawlty angrily attacking his car with a tree branch.

Principal's full-time siren sounds

Retired Manchester St School principal Rex Wheeler has more time to spend reconditioning his 1937 Studebaker Gran ...

After 43 years in the district, principal Rex Wheeler has more time for tinkering.


Tasman upset Taranaki

Tasman winger James Lowe shows plenty of commitment on defence against Taranaki's Declan O'Donnell.

A 25-point haul from Mitch Hunt secures Tasman a place in next week's Mitre 10 Cup final.

Men 'fell like cards'

Four men were on the deck outside the Portage Resort Hotel's restaurant and bar in the Marlborough Sounds when a rail ...

A group of men fell off a Marlborough hotel deck "like a pack of cards" after a railing collapsed, a witness says.

Man seriously injured by machinery

A man aged "in his 40s" was trapped in timber yard machinery at a Tasman saw mill and flown to hospital with serious ...

Worker trapped in a timber machine at a Tasman saw mill for more than 30 minutes.

Tale of two MPs

Nick Smith says National will be a formidable force in opposition.

The top of the south looks set to swap one cabinet minister for another.


All access

NZ Access technician Tim Newton lowers himself into a wine tank during a training exercise.

The thought of confined spaces can drive some people up the walls. Not these guys.

Men 'fell like a pack of cards'

Four men were on the deck outside the Portage Resort Hotel's restaurant and bar in the Marlborough Sounds when a rail ...

A group of men fell off a Marlborough hotel deck "like a pack of cards" after a railing collapsed, a witness says.

Think outside the ball

Jemma Funnell shows off a kokedama ball, on display at Thomas's Department Store in Blenheim.

The latest gardening trend to come out of Japan, dubbed the "poor man's bonsai", is bouncing its way to Marlborough.

Cafe starts cup-swap scheme

SwappaCups are made from glass and non-toxic plastic.

BV Gourmet hopes to soon have a revolving door of glass coffee cups, with none going to waste.

South Canterbury

It's coming down

Owner of the Hydro Grand, Allan Booth.

Timaru's Hydro Grand Hotel could be reduced to rubble by the end of November.

Disease 'contained'

22092017 News Photo: TOM LEE/STUFF - Dairy Cow, Farming, Fonterra, Cattle. Milking, Dawn Morning.

Ministry for Primary Industries confident Mycoplasma bovis is contained.

'Cautious optimism'

Federated Farmers South Canterbury chairman Mark Adams.

Hopes and fears have been raised by prominent South Canterbury figures now our new Government has been revealed.

Farewell to commissioner

Fairlie Primary School commissioner Terri Johnstone has said farewell to the school.

Fairlie Primary School is in a state of self-governence once more.


Ex-convict in compo bid

Rex Haig, of Dunedin, is hoping to lodge a compensation claim with the Government.

Rex Haig's murder conviction was quashed, but his fight for justice is far from over.

Location scout's extraordinary life video

Dave Comer was considered New Zealand's first professional film location scout.

From Barry Crump commercials to Peter Jackson blockbusters, Dave Comer connected NZ's landscapes with its people.

Fire rages near Te Anau

A large scrub fire covering more than 1300 hectares started at Mt Prospect Station near Te Anau.

Six helicopters are helping fight an out-of-control Southland blaze that's spread to more than 1300 hectares.

Boy seriously hurt in crash

A rescue helicopter lands at the crash site.

The long weekend is off to a bad start in the South Island, with a three-vehicle crash leaving a boy with serious injuries.


Fire rages near Te Anau

A large scrub fire covering more than 1300 hectares started at Mt Prospect Station near Te Anau.

Six helicopters helping fight out-of-control blaze that's spread to more than 1300 hectares.

Fishing for all

Greg Sheppard, from Te Anau's, Trout Observatory releases a rainbow trout into McGregor's Pond near Te Anau, under the ...

Southerners are spoilt for choice this weekend in terms of things to do.

Southland fraudster sentenced

The Invercargill District Court.

A Southland fraudster who admitted 16 dishonesty charges has been sentenced to community detention.

A passion for the immortal Mustang

Wayne Fabish, of the Taranaki Mustang Club, spent four years building up his 67 Mustang, which he is showing for the ...

The 38th National Mustang Convention taking place in Invercargill this weekend.

Ad Feedback