Government faces High Court proceedings over alleged civilian deaths in Afghanistan video


Lawyers Rodney Harrison, Deborah Manning, and Richard McLeod address media in relation to the High Court proceedings they have filed against the government.

A human rights lawyer has filed proceedings against the government over the decision not to hold an inquiry into a military operation that allegedly killed civilians in Afghanistan.

Deborah Manning confirmed she had filed a request for a judicial review of the decision in the High Court at Wellington on Friday morning.

Investigative journalists Jon Stephenson and Nicky Hager wrote about operation in their 2016 book, Hit and Run

They alleged the raid, known as Operation Burnham, had killed six Afghan villagers and injured 15.

* Bill English says SAS inquiry 'unlikely' after Defence Force attacks Hit and Run inaccuracies
* Six questions we can answer about the SAS incident in Afghanistan, and three we can't
* Former Defence Minister says civilian deaths in Afghanistan were 'an accident'
* Live chat: Nicky Hager on his explosive new book about an SAS raid

Stephenson referred the villagers to Manning after they approached him for help in 2016.

Manning said she was in regular contact with them, and believed they had the right to an "independent and effective" inquiry.

"The toughest thing for those who suffer trauma or abuse is for people to say it didn't happen," she said at a press conference in Auckland.

"They continue to suffer to this day from the devastating effects of that evening." 

Her team was dealing with claims from three Afghans – two from the village of Khak Khuday Dad and one from the village of Naik. Both villages are in Baghlan Province.

Ad Feedback

Rodney Harrison QC, who is working with Manning and Richard McLeod, said the team sought the judicial review of the Government's decision to refer the case to the chief of the Defence Force. It was he who decided not to stage an inquiry into Operation Burnham.

"We say the the chief of the Defence Force was the wrong person to make that decision, and that the decision he did make – to do nothing – was flawed because he had already taken up the position that the allegations were unfounded," Harrison said.

Prime Minister Bill English said in April that there was "no basis" for ordering an inquiry and the war crimes allegations looked "quite far-fetched".

He said classified video confirmed that NZDF personnel took all necessary precautions to ensure minimal opportunity for civilian casualties and destruction of property.

Manning practises in refugee, immigration and human rights law, and also serves as an executive member of the Refugee Council.

She previously acted as a senior legal consultant to Geneva human rights group Al Karama (Dignity), which represents victims of human rights violations in the Arab region.

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers

Harm of HIV questioned

Mikio Filitonga was found guilty of  knowingly infecting a lover with HIV.

Medical advances mean deliberate infection is less harmful, lawyer tells court.

Daktory pair found guilty on cannabis charges

Marijuana growing operation at The Daktory site in Whangarei in December 2016.

Jury trial finds pair involved with Daktory Club guilty on cannabis charges,

Tsunami information boards for beaches

The Whangarei District Council-funded Northland Civil Defence tsunami information board at Tutukaka boat ramp helps ...

New tsunami information boards have been installed a beaches around the Whangarei district.

Child pulled from taxi van wreck video

The remains of the taxi van lay on its side following the crash in Mauku.

Members of public pulled an injured child from the wreckage after a taxi van crashed in a paddock.


Levin's 'field of dreams'

Horowhenua Kāpiti Cricket Association chief executive Dave O'Brien in the Basil Netten Centre at Donnelly Park, Levin.

Cricket fans know of Eden Park and the Basin Reserve. But what about Donnelly Park in Levin?

Lundy appeal begins gallery

Mark Lundy, pictured at his 2015 retrial, has twice been convicted of murdering his wife Christine and their 7-year-old ...

Mark Lundy's appeal against convictions for killing his wife and daughter will probe scientific evidence.

School's 150 years of success

The very smartly dressed Wellington College first XV rugby team from 1884.

Jubilee celebrations underway at Wellington College to mark 150 years educating young Wellingtonians.

Dogs maul seal pups 

A seal pup on the beach at Tangoio in 2015. One was killed by a dog at the seaside town north of Napier last month.

Second young fur seal killed in Hawke's Bay within the past month.


Historic farm and manor for sale

Glenralloch Manor, built in 1912, is the centrepiece of the farm for sale that overlooks Pigeon Bay, Banks Peninsula.

One of New Zealand's earliest sheep and beef farms, on Banks Peninsula, is on the market.

Jail for brutal killing video

Murderer Stephen Findlay appears in the High Court at Dunedin for sentencing.

Stephen Findlay drank and argued with his neighbour. Then one night he bashed her to death before shooting himself.

Horror show at horror show

Interactive theatre experience Dark Lake was a disaster in Christchurch - but the organisers say it was a one-off.

It was supposed to be a chilling interactive theatre show. What they got was a shambles.

Bridging the gap

Sounds Air chief executive Andrew Crawford says if the research stacks up 19-seater Beechcrafts could be flying between ...

Sounds Air could be flying 19-seaters between Chch and Blenheim early next year.


Book mania at new library

The Te Awamutu Library is celebrating its first birthday since opening at its new premises on Selwyn Lane.

Visitor numbers at the new Te Awamutu library have increased by nearly 60 per cent.

Shotgun killing plea

The house in Seddon St, Frankton, where Tiffani Jade Sutcliffe killed Rhys Gordon Williamson.

Tiffany Jade Sutcliffe, 23, has plead guilty to manslaughter of a friend.

Maurice's short sad life

Maurice Junior Papariu Murtagh was found facedown in the carpark of a Rotorua hotel.

He started taking magic mushrooms at seven. By 12 he was inhaling aerosols. At 20, he was found in a car park.

Man dies after delayed hip surgery

The Waikato DHB failed to provide services to a patient with reasonable care and skill.

Elderly man waits 4 days for operation that should have been done within 48 hours of fall.


Mixing pleasure with work

Pukekura Park Tennis Club's business house competition  has reached 50 years.

It's not unusual to play a night of cards after the business house tennis games have ended.

Meth in motel raid

After being found with methamphetamine in a motel room, Melanie Te Peke was sentenced to supervision to get help to ...

"You'd have to be living under a rock to not understand how serious this drug is."

Ships Ahoy! on park lake

There will be many different types of ships sailing in King Edward Park's lake this weekend - very different to those ...

The annual event is sailing into its second decade.

War medals mystery

161017 News Photo. SIMON O'CONNOR/STUFF
Ali and Brian Bollond have found some old war medals and are trying to find out ...

She was polishing her grandfather's treasured medals, when she read another soldier's name.


Bright lights for lost infants video

Addison Murphy, 8, left, and Ruby Marsh, 11, light lanterns in recognition of International Pregnancy and Infant Loss ...

Manawatū remembers the lives of little ones with a lantern release.

'Science cost Lundy' gallery

Mark Lundy, pictured at his 2015 retrial, has twice been convicted of murdering his wife Christine and their 7-year-old ...

Mark Lundy's lawyer opens appeal against the murder convictions.

Booze plan needs proof

Bottle stores and supermarkets are at odds about whether alcohol sales should stop at 9pm. Big Barrel's Baldeep Dhillon ...

Proof is needed to support proposed tougher alcohol controls in the city.

Scout's service recognised

Robert Johnston has completed the Queen's Scout Award and Duke of Edinburgh Gold award.

Five years of work has earned a Pohangina teen a double dose of recognition.


Corbett realises Ironman dream

Louise Corbett can finally relax after her epic Ironman adventure.

Louise Corbett finishes Hawaiian Ironman six months after horrific training accident. 

Poachers 'too lazy'

Two hunters scaled a security gate to access a 580-hectare property near Pelorus River. (File photo)

But they weren't too lazy to climb a 2-metre gate 18 times in 15 months.

New beginning for old pub

Jaks Island co-founders Jessie Verhoef, Kate Manley, and Ali Slotemaker, at their new establishment on Bridge St.

A cafe, a business and some apartments.

The army is coming

USAF C-17 Globemasters carry out air load drops at Lake Station, Saint Arnaud as part of Exercise Southern Katipo 2015.

Military vehicles and personnel will be visible in the region from Wednesday as part of a big training exercise.


Poachers too lazy to go around

Two hunters scaled a security gate to access a 580-hectare property near Pelorus River. (File photo)

But they weren't too lazy to climb a 2-metre gate 18 times in 15 months.

Costly midnight raid

Two men caught poaching by a deer farmer in Awatere Valley high country have been fined. (File photo)

A second poacher has been fined after a deer farmer caught the men in action.

Mum's Facebook revenge backfires

Screen shots posted by Lisa Maree Moynihan attacking people she claimed ripped off her son were shared more than 100 times.

A mum decided to publicly shame an alleged dealer when her son didn't receive his cannabis. It didn't go very well.

Meat-eating snail found in Sounds

A DOC ranger holds two endangered snail shells; the rhytida o'connori, left, and the powelliphanta. (File photo)

The elusive gastropod, dubbed the Sumo wrestler of the snail world, is rarely seen in the Sounds. Then two show up at once.

South Canterbury

No potato shortage in Sth Canty

Heartland Potato Chips manager Charlotte Bowan with her father, owner Raymond Bowan.

Heartland Potato Chips and Makikihi Fries both doing well this season.

'Ripped from my life'

Oamaru pensioner William Arthur Lee arrives at Timaru District Court on Monday morning with defence counsel Michael de Buyzer

Oamaru pensioner sentenced after killing a man he drove into on a pavement.

Burner opposition is 'about fairness'

Former South Canterbury Regional Air Plan Liaison Committee secretary Tom O'Connor, left, with former chairman Mark ...

Residents are not giving up on woodburner opposition yet.

Archbold lands new contract

Shane Archbold will ride for Irish Pro Continental team Aqua Blue Sport in 2018, after a horror run of injuries.

Pro cyclist Shane Archbold will be back riding in Europe after signing with a new team.


Newbee MP plays hurry up and wait during coalition talks

National party Clutha-Southland MP Hamish Walker.

It's hurry up and wait for new MP Hamish Walker during coalition talks.

New wheels for Kai school

Kaitangata Primary School is proud of its new bus. Bus drivers, left, principal Anneta Payne, teacher Ruth Baldwin, ...

Kaitangata Primary School buys new minibus.

Backyard trapping volunteers sought

Wanaka resident Kris Vollebregt caught three rats in her first two weeks of backyard trapping.

If you have a compost bin, you have rats. And that possum in your tree? It's yours, too.

Jaffas to be made in Australia

A Dunedin group pulled out of a plan to keep production of Pineapple Lumps, Jaffas, Buzz Bars and Pinky bars local.

Kiwi favourites will be made across the ditch after Cadbury owner failed to find local manufacturer.


Men lose everything video

A house on Main Street, Wairio in Western Southland, was gutted by fire on Monday morning.

A father and son are left with only the clothes they were wearing, after a house fire.

Old boy new chief

Chris Ramsay will succeed Greg Mulvey as ILT chief executive in 2018.

A return to his home province was just the tonic for incoming ILT chief executive Chris Ramsay.

Meet the NZ Mustangs

Leonie and Garry Heywood with their 1968 Notchback Mustang ahead of the Annual National Mustang Convention at Stadium ...

Around 175 Mustangs have been rounded up for NZ's annual convention of the iconic American sports car.

Victim struck log

Duayne Insley died when he was struck by a log hanging over the river.

The man who was killed in a jetboating accident struck a log hanging over a channel of water.

Ad Feedback