Transport minister says Greens' light rail cost estimate way off track

An artist's impression of what light rail advocates hoped trains running along Lambton Quay would look like.
LIGHT RAIL TRANSIT ASSOCIATION/SUPPLIED

An artist's impression of what light rail advocates hoped trains running along Lambton Quay would look like.

Transport Minister Simon Bridges says the Green Party severely undershot the cost of bringing light rail to Wellington, which he says could be upwards of $1.2 billion.

The Greens have announced plans to establish light rail between Wellington Railway Station and Newtown by 2025, and extend it to the airport by 2027, at an estimated upfront cost of $630-700 million.

National, meanwhile, has proposed to invest $37m over three years to improve the city's commuter rail network, but has made no mention of light rail.

The Green Party has proposed light rail to Wellington Airport by 2027.
Supplied

The Green Party has proposed light rail to Wellington Airport by 2027.

Bridges said the party did not support the Greens' policy, based purely on cost for what was a "very limited line".

READ MORE:
Transport group wants review of proposed light rail route
Light rail route needs to be locked in now, expert says
Auckland light rail plans boost for option in Wellington
Wellington drivers average just 27kmh during rush-hour
Solving Wellington's congestion problem no easy task
Greens plan light rail to airport by 2027

"The estimated costs I've seen put it around $1.2b, but the reality is, internationally, there's many examples of cost blowouts for these sorts of projects where they go much higher than what's originally estimated."

Labour transport spokesman Michael Wood says the party wants to fast-track a feasibility study for light rail in the capital.
Matt Bowen

Labour transport spokesman Michael Wood says the party wants to fast-track a feasibility study for light rail in the capital.

The Government is, however, part of the Let's Get Wellington Moving working group, along with Wellington City Council and Greater Wellington Regional Council, exploring the possibility of future-proofing a rapid bus route through the central city for light rail conversion.

The Greens say light rail would result in a seven-minute time saving between the railway station and Newtown, as well as slashing the number of buses on the Golden Mile by 40 per cent, and reducing central city traffic during business hours.

A Wellington public transport spine study, completed in 2014, also found there would be a seven-minute time saving between the two points by 2031, but put the upfront cost at $940m, and concluded a rapid bus route was a better option.

Transport Minister Simon Bridges says the Greens' plan for light rail is unrealistic.
CHRISTEL YARDLEY/STUFF

Transport Minister Simon Bridges says the Greens' plan for light rail is unrealistic.

Bridges said further rapid transport proposals were likely to come out of the working group's research, which the Government would be likely to support.

Ad Feedback

"Rapid bus transit, I think, probably being the most likely of those scenarios to improve getting in and around the city of Wellington."

Greens transport spokeswoman Julie Anne Genter said there were more than 170 cities around the world, of similar size to Wellington, that had successful light rail systems.

New Zealand First transport spokesman Denis O'Rourke wants to phase out liquid gas taxes in favour of road pricing charges.
David Hallett

New Zealand First transport spokesman Denis O'Rourke wants to phase out liquid gas taxes in favour of road pricing charges.

She said 50 per cent of the cost should come from the national land transport fund, with the rest coming from local government.

Labour transport spokesman Michael Wood said the party was committed to providing a rapid public transport system between Wellington Railway Station and the airport, and wanted to commission a feasibility study into light rail within the next year.

"The problem with our big cities is they haven't had integrated, long-range public transport planning to link public transport modes together.

Green Party transport spokesperson Julie Anne Genter says light rail is about more than just transport.
DEAN KOZANIC/STUFF

Green Party transport spokesperson Julie Anne Genter says light rail is about more than just transport.

"Something absolutely has to be put in place between the city centre and the airport."

Bus rapid transit and light rail were the two best options to move large numbers of people quickly and reliably, Wood said.

The party had not discussed how the funding should be split between central and local government.

NZ First transport spokesman Denis O'Rourke said the party would push for two light rail routes in Wellington, the first between the airport and CBD within five years, and the second connecting the CDB and the Interislander ferry terminal at a later date.

Road user charges would be introduced to top up the land transport fund, from which 75 per cent of the construction cost would come, O'Rourke said.

"The land transport fund is already under stress. It's no longer viable to rely on petrol taxes alone."

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Cyclists learn from the master video

Netherlands ambassador Rob Zaggman is calling for more students to ride into schools.

The Netherlands ambassador joined Auckland school students to promote cycling in the city.

Habitat helps Kaikohe family

Habitat for Humanity Northland General Manager Carina Dickson with Athena and Te Akau.

New homeowners Te Akau, Athena and their children have been handed the keys to their new Habitat home in Kaikohe.

AT staff fly business class

Auckland Transport spent $600,000 between January 2016 and August 2017 on 213 international flights.

Auckland Transport staff fly business class for nearly a quarter of all overseas work trips.

Harm of HIV questioned

Mikio Filitonga was found guilty of  knowingly infecting a lover with HIV.

Medical advances mean passing on infection is less harmful, lawyer tells court.

Wellington

Levin's 'field of dreams'

Horowhenua Kāpiti Cricket Association chief executive Dave O'Brien in the Basil Netten Centre at Donnelly Park, Levin.

Cricket fans know of Eden Park and the Basin. But what about Donnelly Park in Levin?

HIV 'harm' questioned

Mikio Filitonga was found guilty of  knowingly infecting a lover with HIV.

Medical advances mean passing on infection is less harmful, lawyer tells court.

20,000 All Whites tickets sold

All Whites fans show their support during their recent World Cup qualifier against the Solomon Islands.

Football's big day in Wellington on track for a full house as ticket sales run hot in pre-sale.

Attackers sought in teen assault

Police are calling for witnesses after a 15-year-old boy was assaulted by a trio of attackers in Hastings.

A 15-year-old is in a serious condition and police are looking for three attackers.

Canterbury

Historic farm and manor for sale

Glenralloch Manor, built in 1912, is the centrepiece of the farm for sale that overlooks Pigeon Bay, Banks Peninsula.

One of New Zealand's earliest sheep and beef farms, on Banks Peninsula, is on the market.

Jail for brutal killing video

Murderer Stephen Findlay appears in the High Court at Dunedin for sentencing.

Stephen Findlay drank and argued with his neighbour. Then one night he bashed her to death before shooting himself.

Horror show at horror show

Interactive theatre experience Dark Lake was a disaster in Christchurch - but the organisers say it was a one-off.

It was supposed to be a chilling interactive theatre show. What they got was a shambles.

Bridging the gap

Sounds Air chief executive Andrew Crawford says if the research stacks up 19-seater Beechcrafts could be flying between ...

Sounds Air could be flying 19-seaters between Chch and Blenheim early next year.

Waikato

Mother's phone scam taxi ride

Dimpi Nirmal, left and husband Vineet have $1900 worth of iTunes vouchers as a reminder of the phone scam.

They hacked her husband's phone, threatened his life then ordered her a taxi to an iTunes store.

Shot before threesome

Tiffani Jade Sutcliffe asked if a shotgun was loaded before pulling the trigger and killing Rhys Gordon Williamson

It was meant to be an evening of drug-taking and group sex. It ended in anger and death.

Maurice's short sad life

Maurice Junior Papariu Murtagh was found facedown in the carpark of a Rotorua hotel.

He started taking magic mushrooms at 7. Soon he was inhaling aerosols. At 20, he was dead.

Man dies after delayed hip surgery

The Waikato DHB failed to provide services to a patient with reasonable care and skill.

Elderly man waits 4 days for operation that should have been done within 48 hours of fall.

Taranaki

Climbing Everest in Taranaki

Hasely Lobb will be climbing the equivalent height of Everest over the month of November, taking it a step at a time ...

To climb the equivalent height of Mt Everest, you need to do Paritutu 90 times or Mt Taranaki six times.

A woodwork win

Taranaki wood work artists Doreen Hooper and Bruce Cowley.

"You start with bits of wood and hopefully don't end up with firewood at the end."

Mixing pleasure with work

Pukekura Park Tennis Club's business house competition  has reached 50 years.

It's not unusual to play a night of cards after the business house tennis games have ended.

The importance of working in

Low-intensity exercise can be the key to not burning out.

OPINION: Working out is great but it needs to be paired with a good amount of rest and recovery.

Manawatu

$32,500 for a landline

Bill Tooley is unable to connect a St John Medical Alarm because Chorus needs to extend its network.

Manawatū man can't connect a medical alarm because Chorus needs to extend its network.

'Science cost Lundy' gallery

Mark Lundy, pictured at his 2015 retrial, has twice been convicted of murdering his wife Christine and their 7-year-old ...

Mark Lundy's lawyer opens appeal against the murder convictions.

Bright lights for lost infants video

Addison Murphy, 8, left, and Ruby Marsh, 11, light lanterns in recognition of International Pregnancy and Infant Loss ...

Manawatū remembers the lives of little ones with a lantern release.

Booze plan needs proof

Bottle stores and supermarkets are at odds about whether alcohol sales should stop at 9pm. Big Barrel's Baldeep Dhillon ...

Proof is needed to support proposed tougher alcohol controls in the city.

Nelson

Triumph after terrible cycle crash

Louise Corbett can finally relax after her epic Ironman adventure.

Six months after being broken in a cycle crash, Nelson's Louise Corbett finishes the Hawaiian Ironman. 

Poachers 'too lazy'

Two hunters scaled a security gate to access a 580-hectare property near Pelorus River. (File photo)

But they weren't too lazy to climb a 2-metre gate 18 times in 15 months.

New beginning for old pub

Jaks Island co-founders Jessie Verhoef, Kate Manley, and Ali Slotemaker, at their new establishment on Bridge St.

A cafe, a business and some apartments.

The army is coming

USAF C-17 Globemasters carry out air load drops at Lake Station, Saint Arnaud as part of Exercise Southern Katipo 2015.

Military vehicles and personnel will be visible in the region from Wednesday as part of a big training exercise.

Marlborough

Convoys on a roll

Soldiers on Operation Exercise Southern Katipo give sentry duty while camp is set up at Omaka; from left, Private Weir ...

Exercise Southern Katipo is underway in Marlborough with soldiers and equipment being transferred on the alternate Picton to Christchurch route this week.

Revenge backfires

Screen shots posted by Lisa Maree Moynihan attacking people she claimed ripped off her son were shared more than 100 times.

A mum decided to shame an alleged dealer on Facebook when her son didn't receive his cannabis. 

Poachers too lazy to go around

Two hunters scaled a security gate to access a 580-hectare property near Pelorus River. (File photo)

But they weren't too lazy to climb a 2-metre gate 18 times in 15 months.

Costly midnight raid

Two men caught poaching by a deer farmer in Awatere Valley high country have been fined. (File photo)

A second poacher has been fined after a deer farmer caught the men in action.

South Canterbury

Shearing shed gutted

Bruce Rogers surveys the damage to his shearing shed after the fire on Monday night.

Fire crews forced to cut holes in wool shed to extinguish "well involved" fire near Geraldine.

'Ripped from my life'

Oamaru pensioner William Arthur Lee arrives at Timaru District Court on Monday morning with defence counsel Michael de Buyzer

Oamaru pensioner sentenced after killing a man he drove into on a pavement.

No potato shortage in Sth Canty

Heartland Potato Chips manager Charlotte Bowan with her father, owner Raymond Bowan.

Heartland Potato Chips and Makikihi Fries both doing well this season.

Burner opposition is 'about fairness'

Former South Canterbury Regional Air Plan Liaison Committee secretary Tom O'Connor, left, with former chairman Mark ...

Residents are not giving up on woodburner opposition yet.

Otago

Backyard trapping volunteers sought video

Wanaka resident Kris Vollebregt caught three rats in her first two weeks of backyard trapping.

If you have a compost bin, you have rats. And that possum in your tree? It's yours, too.

Newbee MP plays hurry up and wait during coalition talks

National party Clutha-Southland MP Hamish Walker.

It's hurry up and wait for new MP Hamish Walker during coalition talks.

New wheels for Kai school

Kaitangata Primary School is proud of its new bus. Bus drivers, left, principal Anneta Payne, teacher Ruth Baldwin, ...

Kaitangata Primary School buys new minibus.

Jaffas to be made in Australia

A Dunedin group pulled out of a plan to keep production of Pineapple Lumps, Jaffas, Buzz Bars and Pinky bars local.

Kiwi favourites will be made across the ditch after Cadbury owner failed to find local manufacturer.

Southland

Men lose everything video

A house on Main Street, Wairio in Western Southland, was gutted by fire on Monday morning.

A father and son are left with only the clothes they were wearing, after a house fire.

Old boy new chief

Chris Ramsay will succeed Greg Mulvey as ILT chief executive in 2018.

A return to his home province was just the tonic for incoming ILT chief executive Chris Ramsay.

Meet the NZ Mustangs

Leonie and Garry Heywood with their 1968 Notchback Mustang ahead of the Annual National Mustang Convention at Stadium ...

Around 175 Mustangs have been rounded up for NZ's annual convention of the iconic American sports car.

Victim struck log

Duayne Insley died when he was struck by a log hanging over the river.

The man who was killed in a jetboating accident struck a log hanging over a channel of water.

Ad Feedback