'Penalised for doing the right thing' - man cries foul over fiancee's visa rejection video

DAVID WALKER/Stuff

Seamus Robertson is in a battle with Immigration New Zealand after his Vietnamese partner, Pham Thu Thuong Nguyen, was denied a working visa.

A North Canterbury man faces having to leave his terminally ill father to be with his fiancee after her application to stay in the country was declined.

Kirk Robertson, known as Seamus, says he feels "penalised for doing the right thing" after he and his Vietnamese fiancee, Pham​ Thu Thuong​ Nguyen​, came to New Zealand last December after the death of his mother.

The couple, who started a relationship in 2016 after meeting in Vietnam the year before, moved to the small town of Eyrewell, northwest of Christchurch, so Robertson could look after his 77-year-old father and take over the family business.

Seamus Robertson with his fiancee, Pham Thu Thuong Nguyen, at his father's property in Eyrewell, where the couple have ...
DAVID WALKER/STUFF

Seamus Robertson with his fiancee, Pham Thu Thuong Nguyen, at his father's property in Eyrewell, where the couple have been living together.

Robertson had been teaching in Australia for the past 20 years and had to take time off work to help run Angus Robertson Mechanical after his father was diagnosed with terminal prostate cancer.

READ MORE:
Immigration NZ to boot out top pianist, pregnant and alone
Couple leave New Zealand after former associate minister refuses to intervene
Family separated over Immigration NZ 'instability' concerns

Pham Thu Thuong Nguyen, known as Thuong, applied for a one-year Partner of a New Zealander Work Visa in July ahead of their wedding, planned for October.

The couple plan to get married in October, but Immigration New Zealand has declined Thuong's visa to stay in the country.
DAVID WALKER/STUFF

The couple plan to get married in October, but Immigration New Zealand has declined Thuong's visa to stay in the country.

Two months later, Immigration New Zealand (INZ) declined the application, stating it was "not satisfied that you and your partner are living together in a genuine and stable relationship".

Robertson said the couple felt they were being "penalised" for "doing the right thing by looking after my father". 

They planned to appeal the decision but would move back to Australia if it was rejected, placing the future of the family's company at risk, he said.

"It's put me in the position where I might have to leave the country to be with the woman I love and the woman who will soon be my wife.

Ad Feedback

"We'd have to leave my father alone on a rural property with an engineering business in the last years of his life, and that is not acceptable."

Figures provided by INZ showed 2955 work visas requested under the partnership category were declined in the 2016-17 financial year, while 37,794 were approved.

INZ asked Thuong in September for more information about her living circumstances and the nature of her relationship with Robertson.

Robertson said it had been difficult to prove the couple lived together because they were staying with his father and there were no bills or tenancy agreement bearing their names. 

He believed that was why INZ turned down the application, despite the fact the couple supplied more than 100 pages documenting their relationship.

"We don't have many letters with both of our names on them as we have my father's name on all the bills," he said.

"We would not be living here if my mother was still alive. We are being penalised for looking after our business and my father."

INZ area manager Marcelle Foley said it was the responsibility of the visa applicant to supply all the evidence they wanted to be considered when making the application.

"There was not sufficient evidence to satisfy the immigration officer regarding the extent and nature of a shared residence, financial interdependence and joint decision-making," she said.

Thuong, who had been in New Zealand on a visitor visa, was told she had 42 days to appeal the decision or leave the country.

Robertson had written to Immigration Minister Michael Woodhouse asking for a review of the application process.

In a letter responding to his request, a staffersaid it would likely take five months to consider because of the large number of requests the minister received.

Waimakariri MP Matt Doocey backed Thuong's bid for a visa and had written to Associate Minister of Immigration Scott Simpson saying he was happy to support her appeal.

 - The Press

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

'That's our son'

Cory Parish kisses the Caulfield Cup following his upset win aboard Boom Time.

The kid from nowhere who has been through all the struggles you could imagine never gave up on the dream.

Derelict property for sale: $8m video

Only the concrete framework of an unfinished house remains on a derelict site for sale near Auckland's Takapuna beach.

An unfinished house which had been at the centre of a neighbourhood dispute could sell for more than $8m.

Girls rule at graffiti festival

Auckland-based muralist Adore (aka Emily Gardener) prepares for three days of painting at the Graffiato festival in ...

Seven of the 10 graffiti artists this year are women.

Council should butt out on smoking

The Auckland Council has signed on to a government plan to make New Zealand smokefree by 2025.

OPINION: Damien Grant does not want local government telling him what he can do to his own body.

Wellington

Building bridges to the skies

James McLennan, workshop manager at J & D McLennan Engineers, is the third generation of his family to build air bridges.

Having his work walked all over gives third-generation engineer James McLennan great satisfaction.

Quake near Kaikōura

A 5.4 earthquake has rattled Kaikōura.

Workers in tunnels near Kaikōura safe after 5.4m quake hit.

As many one-liners as birthdays

Kapiti Coast woman Evelyn Hutchins on the eve of her 104th birthday.

Sharp memories, sharp wit: more than 103 years of NZ history and life for Evelyn Hutchins.

Free-to-air rugby tests a no-go

New Zealanders may not have minded not having free-to-air All Blacks' tests, following their shock loss to the Wallabies ...

It's not part of a coalition deal with NZ First, Labour confirms.

Canterbury

Drunk teen's crash shocks

All four occupants of the car that crashed in Central Otago were intoxicated.

Intoxicated parent a passenger when drunk, unlicensed 15yo crashed car.

Quake near Kaikōura

Guests staying the Kaikoura Boutique Hotel won't forget Sunday's 5.4 magnitude earthquake.

Hotel occupants rattled town hit by 5.4 magnitude earthquake.

Cold climbers rescued 

Chris Prudden​, leader of Wakatipu LandSAR's alpine cliff rescue team.

"Shortcut" leads to 10-hour overnight stay in freezing conditions for two climbers.

Kiwi mountaineering pioneer dies

Ed Cotter, pictured on his way to Everest Base Camp in 2008, was the last surviving member of the 1951 New Zealand ...

Ed Cotter, New Zealand's other renowned mountaineering Edmund, has died aged 90.

Waikato

Orcas scare swimmers video

The fin looks menacing in the water behind the swimmers at Hot Water Beach.

The killer whales were thought to be feasting on stingrays.

Joyride halted

Police pursued a trail bike through the streets of Melville on Sunday afternoon.

They zoomed through the streets of Melville on a trail bike - no helmets on. Then the cops spotted 'em.

Life changed forever

Tayla Holmes had a look at what was left of her car once she got out of hospital.

Tayla Holmes survived the crash, but she'll never be the same.

Boy exhibits trains at first show

Jonathan Siddapur, 11, spent two years building his first layout.

The 11 year old is the youngest exhibitor at the Model Railway Exhibition.

Taranaki

Good speeds at trolley derby

221017 News Photo. SIMON O'CONNOR/STUFF
Trolley Derby in Eltham.

Fire truck beats tank and all comers in downhill trolley race.

Danger on the roads

A car was left extensively damaged after it rolled multiple times near Mt Messenger.

A spate of crashes keep crews busy this Labour Weekend.

Tough end to Cooper's tenure

Colin Cooper's tenure at Taranaki has ended.

"I'm disappointed, the team was good enough to have a home final here."

Here comes the model railway video

One of the trains pulls into the New Plymouth station at the New Plymouth Model Railway Club.

One of the tracks is a real life simulation of a train journey from New Plymouth to Palmerston North.

Manawatu

Toned, tanned and taunt gallery

Bodybuilding contestants in the novice shape category.

Bodybuilders from throughout the country flex their muscles in Palmerston North.

Mayor's hemp vision

Horowhenua mayor Michael Feyen wants the Horowhenua District Council to back hemp farming.

Horowhenua mayor Michael Feyen wants the council to back hemp farming.

Hartley's F1 debut video

NZ's Brendon Hartley during practice for the United States Formula One Grand Prix at Circuit of The Americas in Austin, ...

Brendon Hartley finishes F1 US Grand Prix qualifying in 18th before penalties are applied.

Farm worker unfairly sacked

Federated Farmers representative David Lee-Jones was found to have unjustifiably dismissed an employee.

Federated Farmers representative must pay up for breaching a fixed-term worker's rights.

Nelson

Troubled school looks to the future

Golden Bay High School in Takaka has been under statutory management since March.

Outside governance has been appointed to manage a Takaka school and a public meeting will be held next week to discuss its future. 

Makos headed for final

Tasman Makos captain Alex Ainley is welcomed home by his daughters Emilia, left, and Kaiye at Nelson Airport after the ...

The Tasman Makos are now preparing to take on Canterbury in Saturday's premiership rugby final.

Quake shakes Kaikōura

A 5.4 earthquake has rattled Kaikōura.

Workers in tunnels near Kaikōura safe after 5.4m quake hit.

Special Olympics flame in Nelson

Claire Robertson of Nelson police passes the flame to Special Olympics athlete Fraser McManus during the inaugural torch ...

Intellectually disabled athletes take part in Nelson leg of torch relay to launch games.

Marlborough

All access

NZ Access technician Tim Newton lowers himself into a wine tank during a training exercise.

The thought of confined spaces can drive some people up the walls. Not these guys.

Men 'fell like a pack of cards'

Four men were on the deck outside the Portage Resort Hotel's restaurant and bar in the Marlborough Sounds when a rail ...

A group of men fell off a Marlborough hotel deck "like a pack of cards" after a railing collapsed, a witness says.

Think outside the ball

Jemma Funnell shows off a kokedama ball, on display at Thomas's Department Store in Blenheim.

The latest gardening trend to come out of Japan, dubbed the "poor man's bonsai", is bouncing its way to Marlborough.

Cafe starts cup-swap scheme

SwappaCups are made from glass and non-toxic plastic.

BV Gourmet hopes to soon have a revolving door of glass coffee cups, with none going to waste.

South Canterbury

Back in town after 56 years video

Joe Gillman, 76, made the journey from Stillwater on the West Coast in his 1935 Ford V8 Coupe, to take part in the ...

Motoring enthusiast makes the journey from the West Coast in his 1935 Ford V8 Coupe to take part in the Waimate 50.

ECan waiver for some

10082016  News John Bisset/FairfaxNZ.  Tom O'Connor with his road cones he purchased so he can warn motorists of flooding

Struggling households can apply for a temporary woodburner exemption.

Timaru man flown to Christchurch

Police attended a crash at Maungati, which saw a man with serious injuries flown to Christchurch.

Westpac Rescue Helicopter takes Timaru man to Christchurch Hospital after vehicle rolls at Maungati.

Winchester Rodeo ropes them in video

Ginny Nelson tosses the rope during the team roping event at the Winchester Rodeo.

About 3000 attend rodeo event.

Otago

Encouraging start for Southern United

Southern United coach Paul O'Reilly.

Southern United have come from behind twice to secure a hard fought 2-2 draw against Auckland City in Dunedin.

Drunk teen's crash shocks

All four occupants of the car that crashed in Central Otago were intoxicated.

Intoxicated parent a passenger when drunk, unlicensed 15-year-old crashed car.

Climbers rescued after freezing night

Chris Prudden​, leader of Wakatipu LandSAR's alpine cliff rescue team.

So-called shortcut leads to 10-hour overnight stay in freezing conditions for two Aussie climbers.

Ex-convict fears 'war on me'

Rex Haig, of Dunedin, is hoping to lodge a compensation claim with the Government.

Rex Haig's murder conviction was quashed, but his fight for justice is far from over.

Southland

Location scout's extraordinary life video

Dave Comer was considered New Zealand's first professional film location scout.

From Barry Crump commercials to Peter Jackson blockbusters, Dave Comer connected NZ's landscapes with its people.

Ex-convict fears 'war on me'

Rex Haig, of Dunedin, is hoping to lodge a compensation claim with the Government.

Rex Haig's murder conviction was quashed, but his fight for justice is far from over.

Garage fire being investigated

A garage on a Conon St, Invercargill, property was gutted by fire on Sunday afternoon.

Fire investigators have been requested following a garage fire in Invercargill.

Climbers rescued after freezing night

Chris Prudden​, leader of Wakatipu LandSAR's alpine cliff rescue team.

So-called shortcut leads to 10-hour overnight stay in freezing conditions for two Aussie climbers.

Ad Feedback