Police discourage victims pressing charges against officers, offer mediation instead

Tyler Pogan claimed he was pepper sprayed and repeatedly punched by a police officer during an unlawful arrest.

Tyler Pogan claimed he was pepper sprayed and repeatedly punched by a police officer during an unlawful arrest.

Police bosses are defending themselves against claims of special treatment as they're accused of avoiding prosecutions against their own officers.

It's emerged police have been offering victims restorative justice sessions with alleged police offenders as an alternative to pressing charges in court.

Restorative justice is typically ordered by a judge once a person has pleaded guilty and shown they are remorseful.

Shannon Parker said she was concerned police were being held to a different standard than the public.

Shannon Parker said she was concerned police were being held to a different standard than the public.

However the police sessions involve no admission of guilt from officers involved, allowing them to keep a clean record and avoid facing any legal repercussions.

READ MORE: Police officer under investigation over alleged assault

Tyler Pogan was offered the mediation after complaining he was pepper sprayed and repeatedly punched by a police officer during an arrest in Gisborne in October 2014.

IPCA general manager Warren Young disputed there was anything untoward about the mediation sessions.

IPCA general manager Warren Young disputed there was anything untoward about the mediation sessions.

Senior constable Steve Middleton is alleged to have punched Pogan six times in the side of the head as he lay on top of him, after Pogan threatened to kill him "and your kids".

Pogan was charged with disorder, resisting arrest, assaulting a police officer and threatening to kill the officer.

But the resisting and assault charges were thrown out by Judge Warren Cathcart, who said the arrest was unlawful. Pogan was later convicted of threatening to kill Middleton. 

Pogan claimed Middleton had committed "some serious crimes" and had "still not been held accountable for his actions". 

Ad Feedback

He said he was contacted by the Independent Police Conduct Authority (IPCA) which suggested he consider mediation. The IPCA is the government agency responsible for monitoring police activities.

He said he was later told by police it would provide him with an opportunity to air his grievances against Middleton.

Pogan declined after learning Middleton would avoid criminal charges if he agreed to the mediation.

"It's like they're trying to sweep it all under the rug and make me feel good," Pogan said.

"I don't know why or how they've been allowed to drag it out this long. Are police above the law?"

Superintendent Anna Jackson, police national manager for professional conduct, confirmed the offer of mediation.

"Police thought it would be helpful for Mr Pogan to meet senior constable Middleton face-to-face to discuss how he felt," she said.

"It is not unusual for police to consider mediation or other alternatives to prosecution in cases involving the public and police officers, on a case-by-case basis."

Shannon Parker, president of the NZ Police Conduct Association, a public watchdog, said she was concerned using mediation as an alternative to prosecution meant police were being held to a different standard.

"Police staff accused of offending are not held to the same account as civilians who commit the same offences," she said.

"It basically keeps everything off the record, and I think it's just a way of covering up police offending."

Parker said she was also concerned the IPCA had "crossed a line of independence" in approaching Pogan about mediation.

"The authority's mission statement is to promote public trust and confidence in the New Zealand Police," she said.

"This shouldn't be achieved by trying to keep police staff out of the courts."

IPCA general manager Warren Young disputed there was anything untoward about the approach.

He said from the authority's perspective, using restorative justice as an alternative to court proceedings was "common practice".

"In some cases, it will provide a more meaningful outcome for both parties, and more effectively hold the offender to account, than prosecution and conviction," Young said.

"It is included as one of our options for addressing complaints by way of a facilitated resolution rather than lengthy and often unproductive investigations."

The mediation alternative is unique to cases involving police officers.

Parker said she was unaware of any incidents where a civilian victim and civilian offender had been offered restorative justice instead of court proceedings.

Pogan said he declined the mediation because he wants to see his alleged attacker face prosecution over the incident.

Three years later, he's yet to hear from police whether Middleton will face criminal charges.

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers

Power lines dangle after crash

Homes in north Auckland are without power after a car crashed into a rural pole.

People in car "unsafe" after wires were pulled down by a separate vehicle, cutting power for 17km north of Auckland.

Waititi-less red carpet for Thor video

Cohen Holloway and Rachel House stand for a photo at Thor: Ragnarok red carpet Auckland premiere.

Auckland rolls out the red carpet for Thor, but where are the stars?

Prepare to be amazed

Rob Zabrecky, Shin Lim, Colin Cloud, Charlie Frye and Co, and Hector Mancha will be performing at The Regent.

Group of touring magicians keen to wow magic fans.

Man stabbed on Kawau Island

A 66-year-old man will appear in the North Shore District Court over the incident.

A man in his 60s with stab wounds was flown from Kawau Island to hospital in a moderate condition.


Old trains become graffiti targets

Old commuter trains stored at Upper Hutt railway yards have been vandalised and will be removed.

Trains stored in Upper Hutt will be on the move again after problems with vandalism.

Coke vs. capital cafe

$110m of taxpayer funds has gone into Coca Cola.

Wellington cafe thought its name was innocent enough, until Coca-Cola's lawyers came calling.

Euthanasia referendum more likely

MPs will now be allowed a conscience vote on whether the issue of legalising voluntary euthanasia should be decided by a ...

Labour-NZ First coalition deal brings country a step closer to public vote on euthanasia.

Killed on way home from funeral

Jude Shadbolt died when her car left the road near Raupunga, near Wairoa, last Friday.

Wairoa grandmother dies in a car crash after attending her sister's funeral.


Highly-decorated soldier dies

Major-General Walter "Sandy" Thomas was decorated for bravery four times, received the Military Cross twice and was ...

Major-General Walter "Sandy" Thomas was decorated for bravery four times & then some.

Raid ends online drugs

Three people with with alleged connections to the King Cobra gang were arrested in an August 31 raid Armed Offenders ...

Man offering cannabis for sale on social media pleads guilty after police raided his home in connection with a gang.

Woman dies after falling from bike

An elderly woman has died after falling from her bicycle on Monday. (File photo)

An 81-year-old woman has died after falling off her bicycle on a rural Canterbury road.

Txt My Lunch feeds hungry kids video

Txt My Lunch founder Johannes Tietzse hopes to sell the company's pre-ordered lunches at all schools that have a ...

Donate a lunch or order a nutritious one for your child to avoid giving them cash.


Waikato world class pinot noir

The five year wait has paid off for Andy Anderson who won the Best Pinot Noir trophy with the 2012 wine.

Looking for the world's best pinot noir - look no further than the Waikato.

Massuer not guilty

Masseur Keith Ashley Dobson has been found not guilty of indecent assault.

Hamilton massage therapist is cleared of all indecent assault charges after week-long hearing.

Kayaker's near miss video

A kayaker had to be rescued from the Waikato River, near the Huka Falls, on Monday.

The Huka Falls isn't deemed dangerous in kayaking circles, but paddlers need to be up to skill level.

New probe at DHB

Waikato DHB's virtual health app SmartHealth was launched in 2016 (file photo).

Independent probe launched into multimillion-dollar Waikato health app.


The Indian kebab shop

Cheshta Jassal runs most of the day-to-day operation while her husband oversees the management side.

When Jaz Singh and his wife and daughter moved to New Zealand from India, they had no plans to own a Turkish restaurant.

Little comes home

Labour MP Andrew Little, left, was back in his home town of New Plymouth, speaking with locals including Peter Beck of ...

Andrew Little plans to use his position of power to give a voice to New Plymouth and Taranaki in Parliament.

Chopper gets new sponsor

The Taranaki Rescue Helicopter has received a new 3 year sponsorship deal with Fulton Hogan.  TRH trustee and crew ...

The Taranaki Rescue Helicopter is set to benefit from a sponsorship deal with Fulton Hogan.

Highway fixes to be announced

Proposed safety improvements at the Princess St and State Highway 3 intersection should be made publicly available next ...

Public set to find out what NZTA propose to do to make section of State Highway 3 safer.


Farm maps mines of information

Willie Mckay manages information that tracks and maps efforts to reduce erosion.

UNDER THE RADAR: From field to computer and back out to the hills.

Alternative worries

A pathway from James Line to Whakarongo School was designed to keep students and their parents' cars off a major road ...

City council supports southern Manawatū Gorge alternative despite concerns.

Permits needed for roosters

The owner of a miniature Australorp rooster could need a permit to keep the bird in urban Palmerston North.

Roosters reprieved, and cats can delay their operations.

Hartley the real deal in F1

Brendon Hartley's performance in the United States Grand Prix screamed immense potential.

OPINION: Brendon Hartley's F1 debut was much better than 13th place suggests.


Pair rescued after boat capsizes

Nelson harbourmaster Dave Duncan says there have been two "near tragedies" in just over two weeks.

Boaties are being reminded to be prepared after a second "near tragedy" in as many weeks.

Death shock to family

Terry Reynolds,who died after falling while inspecting a lift at the Suter Art Gallery, with his wife Jean.

Family of man who died after art gallery fall says it "should not have happened".

State homes lay empty

A Housing New Zealand house in Norwich St, Stoke has been vacant for four years.

More than 50 people waiting for homes in Nelson while 15 HNZ homes remain vacant.

Beached as

The remains of a fibreglass dinghy towed behind a vehicle for nearly 10kms along roads in Tasman.

A Nelson man thought it was a good idea to steal a dinghy by tying it to the back of his car. Then things got crazier.


Hanging up his helmet video

Justin Leov and his wife Victoria, son Luca and daughter Annabella get to spend more time together now Justin has retired.

Justin Leov has bought the property where he won his first national champs, added a tiny house and plans to develop tracks on the hills around it.

Bus shelter goals: Limited shading?

A hole in the outside area of the bus shelter gives waiting passengers a view of the sky.

New bus shelter ridiculed nationwide for including a hole in its roof had a simple design brief.

Charged with milk powder claim

Maximillian Christian Zucker appeared at the Blenheim District Court on Monday. (File photo)

Police claim the 20-year-old intended to "cause a significant disruption to commercial activity in New Zealand".

Unicycle effort in the balance video

Endurance sportsman Lee Griggs will attempt to cycle the Molesworth on a unicycle to raise funds for mental health.

A few weeks ago, he'd never even been on a unicycle.

South Canterbury

Hitting the pavement

St Josephs School pupil Sarah Dawson, 5, and her friends, are just some of the students who are increasingly walking to ...

A human caterpillar is helping to reduce congestion outside one Timaru primary school.

Dumped tails shock

Dumped lamb tails beside a stream on Mcnairs Road in Temuka.

Pile of lamb tails dumped at the edge of a creek leaves woman "shocked".

'Communication breakdown'

Albury School principal Ken Heaphy.

A limited statutory manager has been appointed at Albury School.

Boat tour proposal

An example of what TEO Limited High Country Cruise boats are expected to be like. The company has lodged a resource ...

Boat tours on Lake Tekapo could soon become a reality, if resource consent is approved.


Big River Raft Race festival to be held at Balclutha

Project Clutha committee members Layla McNutt, Matt Morahan, Laura Moore with Catlins LandSAR former treasurer Lianne ...

Festival to accompany Balclutha's revived Big River Raft Race.

New boss for Aurora Energy

Dr Richard Fletcher has been named as the new chief executive of Aurora Energy.

Dr Richard Fletcher has been named as the new chief executive for Aurora Energy.

Central Otago on a plate

Armando Varlotta, of Armando's Kitchen in Cromwell, won the People's Choice section of the inaugural Central Otago  ...

An Italian inspired dish from a Cromwell chef and rabbit pies have won voters over in an inaugural Central Otago cuisine competition.

Clutha-Southland NZ First MP-elect's first white-hot days in parliament

Clutha-Southland New Zealand First candidate Mark Patterson watching his leader Winston Peters on election night.

First white-hot days in parliament take on the stark-cold reality of government.


Triflor open day a riot of colour

Fields of tulips at the Triflor NZ open day at Edendale.

Fields of tulips provide fundraiser for small Southland town.

Scout award for teen

Te Anau venture Scout Nigel Lambeth has completed the requirements for the highest award a youth scout can be awarded, ...

A Te Anau scout has become the 25th since 1990 to get the highest honour, a Queens Scout Award.

Art in abundance in Te Anau

Glenda Bell, president of the Fiordland Arts Society, takes a close up view of the tail of a  metalwork peacock by guest ...

Te Anau played host to the Fiordland Arts Society's annual multimedia arts exhibition over the long weekend.

Southern DHB selects mental health provider

Adventure Development Limited will serve as preferred youth primary mental health brief intervention services provider ...

A service provider for youth primary mental health has been selected by the Southern DHB.

Ad Feedback